Re: Christians in uniform

[Whitney]

i dont know what you mean, i haven't struck anyone.

I think someone needs to read the forum rules....

[curiosityandthecat]

i dont know what you mean, i haven't struck anyone.

:blink:

A, covering up paedophilia. B, volunteering to kill anywhere governments send them.

A, Catholics, don't apply the failings of one religious organization to all others. B, there's atheists in foxholes, buddy. Religion and patriotism, though conflated often in this country, are not synonymous.

[Tanker]

Jobee shouldn't this question be directed at Christians.

If I may counter your initial question with an equlivalent question:

Why does an atheist who would, presumably, describe himself as a rational thinker go on an atheist forum to ask atheists to speculate on the motivations of christians?

I ditto this.

You seem to be getting upset that a bunch of Atheists wont give you a straight answer on a subject they can't really know. We can make educated guesses but not really claim deffinitively why anyone who is not us decideds to do anything. Go to a Christian forum I think they may be able to tell how Christian feel about it.

See another post on here called==Why are Christians so rude.

You actually responded to me twice. On page 2 and on page 3. What does your post from here http://happyatheistforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=4503 have to do with my response

[jobee]

I'VE often wondered why the pope's never speak up about this anomaly of killer Christians volunteering to go anywhere politicians want killing done. 'You shall not kill' should be taken very serious by senior prelates.

This would get christianity back on track.

http://com4.runboard.com/bcoventryalternativeforums.f6

[jobee]

ou actually responded to me twice. On page 2 and on page 3. What does your post from here http://happyatheistforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=4503 have to do with my response


QUOTE

I've been on Christians forums, some say they are 'not' christians if they volunteer to kill. Some forums just ban me.

But i've never heard a senior prelate condemn killer christians.

http://com4.runboard.com/bcoventryalternativeforums.f6

[jobee]

Mr Pope your members are killing.


http://www.pray4ourforces.org.uk/


http://www.pray4ourforces.org.uk/

[G-Roll]

I don’t understand this…. Are you saying that Christians and Jews shouldn’t be in the military because of the 10 commandments? Who should be then?
And… why do you care what religion the soldiers of your home country are?

[Tanker]

Regardless of your problems finding answers from Christians it still begs the question why ask us? We can only give opinions or at best previous life experiences. We can't give you a diffinitive answer.

It's like asking an Astronomer "why do people read horoscopes?" when a better person to ask is an Astrologist.


You know what I want you to answer? Your own question for us. Since being the subject of the question is not required you obviously have as much as an expert opinion as the next random person. As soon as you answer me about the moral conundrum Christians in uniform face I'll know what you want to hear and I can return the favor.

[curiosityandthecat]

Am I the only one who feels this way?  

[McQ]

Am I the only one who feels this way?  

Definitely not. Excellent visual of the feeling, too.

[Whitney]

I put jobee on a one week ban for not following my instructions

[jobee]

If I may counter your initial question with an equlivalent question:

Why does an atheist who would, presumably, describe himself as a rational thinker go on an atheist forum to ask atheists to speculate on the motivations of christians?

Because lots of them are anti Christian.

[jobee]

Am I the only one who feels this way?  lol

[pinkocommie]

If I may counter your initial question with an equlivalent question:

Why does an atheist who would, presumably, describe himself as a rational thinker go on an atheist forum to ask atheists to speculate on the motivations of christians?

Because lots of them are anti Christian.

That doesn't make sense.

[jobee]

Okay, carry on killing Christians, case closed.