How do modern philosophers answer on question does God exist

Started by Koliat, November 25, 2008, 08:32:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Koliat

Hello there.

The subject here on boards is the subject for my essay on Philosophic Olympiad in Poland. I'm pretty stuck, since I've from Nietzsche to Onfray and Cioran. I have absolutely no idea who to include in next. Do you know any sensible theistic philosophers of twentieth century I could write about next? I thought about Teilhard de Chardin or existentialists, but  they aren't really into the debate on existence of God.

Hopefully looking for replies asap.

Greetings

Koliat

Zarathustra

#1
Quote from: "Koliat"Do you know any sensible theistic philosophers
Now there's a contradiction in terms.  :)
Quoteof twentieth century I could write about next? I thought about Teilhard de Chardin or existentialists, but  they aren't really into the debate on existence of God.
No. What the enlightenment and science has given us the last 200 years, pretty much makes this issue redundant at best. The concept of gods is evidencetranscendant, and therefore empty. It is mentioned from time to time by people that adress the theory of knowledge, and there are plenty of textbooks on the philosophy of religion.
Sam Harris and Daniel Dennett are the only respected contemporary philosophers I know of,  who write about the god debate in particular. They are both atheists though.
"Existentialist" is most often used about the likes of Sartre, who was an atheist. Kierkegaard was a christian, however he made the first steps towards existentialism.  Maybe you can use him (from the 19th century though)?
From the 20th century, I only know of the danish theologian K.E.Løgstrup, who is generally considered as sharp as theistic "philosophers" come.
"Man does not draw his laws from nature, but impose them upon nature" - Kant
[size=85]English is not my native language, so please don't attack my grammar, attack my message instead[/size]

Wechtlein Uns

You have got to be kidding.

Philosophically, the debate about god's existence has pretty much reached a deadlocked standstill. Very little interest in it now a deys. Kind of like a dead forum thread.  :lol:  

Still, you could always go to the nutters on television and catholic radio, if you believe their claims about being followers of "thomas aquinas". lol.
"What I mean when I use the term "god" represents nothing more than an interactionist view of the universe, a particularite view of time, and an ever expansive view of myself." -- Jose Luis Nunez.

Sophus

‎"Christian doesn't necessarily just mean good. It just means better." - John Oliver

Whitney

C.S. Lewis ?  I wouldn't exactly call him sensible but he has written a lot and claims to be an ex atheist.

St. Thomas Aquinas comes to mind...but I forgot what century he's from.  From what I've read of his work, which is actually very little, he was sensible but missed the mark.

Zarathustra

Quote from: "laetusatheos"C.S. Lewis ?  I wouldn't exactly call him sensible but he has written a lot and claims to be an ex atheist.

St. Thomas Aquinas comes to mind...but I forgot what century he's from.  From what I've read of his work, which is actually very little, he was sensible but missed the mark.
C.S. Lewis was NOT a philosopher,and as far as I know a devoted christian. Aquinas is 12th century, not very sensible but medieval.
"Man does not draw his laws from nature, but impose them upon nature" - Kant
[size=85]English is not my native language, so please don't attack my grammar, attack my message instead[/size]

Whitney

Hmm...I've got nothing then.

I'd suggest finding a recently published philosophy of religion textbook.  I couldn't find mine to reference.

Sophus

C.S. Lewis was a theologian. I can't think of any significant modern philosophers who are theists.
‎"Christian doesn't necessarily just mean good. It just means better." - John Oliver

curiosityandthecat

Quote from: "Sophus"C.S. Lewis was a theologian. I can't think of any significant modern philosophers who are theists.

Hmmm... coincidence?  ;)
-Curio

Sophus

Quote from: "curiosityandthecat"Hmmm... coincidence?  ;)

 :banna:  Ha ha. Thanks... what the ruddy hell does that mean anyways?
‎"Christian doesn't necessarily just mean good. It just means better." - John Oliver

curiosityandthecat

Quote from: "Sophus":banna:  Ha ha. Thanks... what the ruddy hell does that mean anyways?

-Curio

Whitney


Sophus

‎"Christian doesn't necessarily just mean good. It just means better." - John Oliver