Happy Atheist Forum

Think of this as a meme.  How do you answer these questions for yourselves?  A lot of Atheists here won't have a problem just shrugging these off, but give them a little thought anyway.  It should be a little fun...


Why do we exist?
What is the best thing about existing?
What is our purpose?
Is the world a better place for having had humans in it?
How can we improve humanity?
What is the best advice or philosophy for living?

What is religion?
Why are there multiple religions?
Should religions be challenged?
Is skepticism a good thing?
Why do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged?
Which religion is right?
Can all religions be correct?
What does fear have to do with belief?
Do we have a need to believe in something?
What is spirituality?


Can religion and science coexist?
What’s the difference between religion and science?
Can a religion change with society?
Was man created or did he evolve?

Is there a God?
What is the definition of God?
What gives you certainty in your belief?
How do you deal with doubt?
Who created God?
Is God male or female?
What does God need from us?
Who is/are the Messiah(s)?
Who is the Devil?

What is faith?
What is a fact?
How can we tell which is which?

What is truth?
How do we determine truth?
Which truth is right?

Is the holy-book(s) literally true?
What is the origin of the holy book(s)?
How do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.?
Can we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest?

What is morality?
Is there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures?
Where does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from?
Is altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity?

What is sin?
What is the punishment for sin?
Is thought the same as deed?
Does God want to test us? Why?

Should a person have sex before marriage?
Is masturbation a sin?
What determines sexual orientation?
Why is God interested in our sexual behavior?
Should women be treated differently than men?

Do we have free will?
Is everything predetermined?
What entity predetermines fate or destiny?

Why is there suffering?
What is best path to happiness?
Does God intercede in human tragedies?

Does prayer work?
If so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters?
If not, why pray?
Does meditation work?
How does meditation work?

What is a soul?
Do animals have souls?
Does a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body?
If a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up?
What purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it?

Is there an Afterlife?
Where is it, where do we go after death?
Why do we need an afterlife?

When does life begin?
When should abortion be allowed?
Is it ever appropriate to kill another person?

What are supernatural beliefs?
Are there extraterrestrials?
Who are they?
Do psychics work, and if you are religious, are they allowed?
Where do the voices in our heads come from?

Will there be a doomsday?
What is the greatest danger facing man’s existence?
How do we stop conflict?
Should different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife?
Should political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy?

~

I obviously don't expect people to answer all of these, just have fun with the philosophical questions of life!

Just so you know, copying giant portions of text from another source without giving credit to the source is not received well here.  I say this because I found that a good deal (if not all) of your questions were listed here word for word -

http://thenatureofexistence.com/about/the-questions/

Is this your website?

Quote from: "KebertX"Think of this as a meme.  How do you answer these questions for yourselves?  A lot of Atheists here won't have a problem just shrugging these off, but give them a little thought anyway.  It should be a little fun...


Why do we exist?

Because of the serendipitous interaction of the laws of physics and chemistry occurring in an environment suited to the development of replicating molecules. From that point natural selection took over. Eventually the positive selection benefits of increased brain capacity lead to the emergent property of consciousness which lead to the question 'Why do we exist?'

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the best thing about existing?

Self awareness.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is our purpose?

In the physical sense, reproduce. In the abstract sense, none. In the personal sense to exploit our consciousness to the maximum.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is the world a better place for having had humans in it?

Pointless question, as there is nobody to define or determine 'better'.

Quote from: "KebertX"can we improve humanity?

Pointless question, as there is nobody to define or determine 'improve'.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the best advice or philosophy for living?

The Golden Rule.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is religion?

Institutionalised superstition.

Quote from: "KebertX"Why are there multiple religions?

Isolated groups of people institutionalised their particular superstitions in different ways.

Quote from: "KebertX"Should religions be challenged?

All ideas should be challenged.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is skepticism a good thing?

Good or bad is not the issue. A sceptical view is the only one that allows a mind to be objective and critical.

Quote from: "KebertX"Why do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged?

Tribalism.

Quote from: "KebertX"Which religion is right?

The one with the most followers, as

Quote from: "KebertX"Can all religions be correct?

As some hold diametrically opposed view, no.

Quote from: "KebertX"What does fear have to do with belief?

Nothing

Quote from: "KebertX"Do we have a need to believe in something?

Some people do, some don't.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is spirituality?

A historical concept born of eating strange mind altering substances or fooling ones own mind into a transcendental state.

Quote from: "KebertX"Can religion and science coexist?

Yes, they always have.

Quote from: "KebertX"What’s the difference between religion and science?

Religion is institutionalised superstition, science is institutionalised curiosity.

Quote from: "KebertX"Can a religion change with society?

Note Catholicism, so Yes.

Quote from: "KebertX"Was man created or did he evolve?

Easiest question so far, evolved.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is there a God?

Probably not.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the definition of God?

Mine. Which is the only valid definition for me as it would be for any person.

Quote from: "KebertX"What gives you certainty in your belief?

You're assuming certainty. I refer you to your question re scepticism.

Quote from: "KebertX"How do you deal with doubt?

I accept it as a natural consequence of my inability to know and assimilate all that is knowable.
 

Quote from: "KebertX"Who created God?

Probably nothing or nobody.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is God male or female?

Probably neither.

Quote from: "KebertX"What does God need from us?

Probably nothing.

Quote from: "KebertX"Who is/are the Messiah(s)?

Probably nobody.

Quote from: "KebertX"Who is the Devil?

A fictitious character used to control naught children by scaring the living shit out of them

Quote from: "KebertX"What is faith?

A self delusional state leading to a reinforcing of the delusion.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is a fact?

Something that can be independently and repeatedly determined.

Quote from: "KebertX"How can we tell which is which?

Faith can not be reliably externally verified, a fact can be reliably externally verified.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is truth?

A fact that has been reliably externally verified.

Quote from: "KebertX"How do we determine truth?

Rigorous, and reliable external verification.

Quote from: "KebertX"Which truth is right?

The one that stands up to rigorous, and reliable external verification.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is the holy-book(s) literally true?

Almost definitely not.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the origin of the holy book(s)?

The human desire to codify behaviour in a tribal setting.

Quote from: "KebertX"How do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.?

Personal experience.

Quote from: "KebertX"Can we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest?

Yes. It is always done.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is morality?

Wishful thinking leading to an idealised view of behaviour.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures?

Yes. The one in your own culture. Everybody else is wrong.

Quote from: "KebertX"Where does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from?

Genes, memes and experience.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity?

Yes. As there probably no God then altruism and morality are probably emergent properties of our species evolution.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is sin?

Doing something you would not want done to you.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the punishment for sin?

Proportionate to the damage done.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is thought the same as deed?

No.

Quote from: "KebertX"Does God want to test us? Why?

Probably not as God probably does not exist.

Quote from: "KebertX"Should a person have sex before marriage?

Personal choice of the adult involved.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is masturbation a sin?

As it hurts nobody, no.

Quote from: "KebertX"What determines sexual orientation?

Genes, memes and experience.

Quote from: "KebertX"Why is God interested in our sexual behavior?

He probably isn't.

Quote from: "KebertX"Should women be treated differently than men?

Yes. Each gender should be treated according to their unique physical needs.

Quote from: "KebertX"Do we have free will?

Yes.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is everything predetermined?

No.

Quote from: "KebertX"What entity predetermines fate or destiny?

None.

Quote from: "KebertX"Why is there suffering?

The interaction of socio economic factors leads to inequalities that lead to suffering.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is best path to happiness?

The one that works for the individual.

Quote from: "KebertX"Does God intercede in human tragedies?

Probably not.

Quote from: "KebertX"Does prayer work?

Probably not.

Quote from: "KebertX"If so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters?

See above.

Quote from: "KebertX"If not, why pray?

See above.

Quote from: "KebertX"Does meditation work?

Don't know, never tried.

Quote from: "KebertX"How does meditation work?

See above

Quote from: "KebertX"What is a soul?

An act of wishful thinking created to overcome a paralysing fear of death that allows our ancestors to function.

Quote from: "KebertX"Do animals have souls?

No, they don't need one.

Quote from: "KebertX"Does a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body?

See above.

Quote from: "KebertX"If a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up?

See above

Quote from: "KebertX"What purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it?

See above.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is there an Afterlife?

Probably not.

Quote from: "KebertX"Where is it, where do we go after death?
Why do we need an afterlife?

See above.

Quote from: "KebertX"When does life begin?

At the point of self awareness.

Quote from: "KebertX"When should abortion be allowed?

Whenever the mother requires it up to the third trimester. After that if continuing the pregnancy would adversely effect the survival or mental well being of the mother.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is it ever appropriate to kill another person?

Yes.

Quote from: "KebertX"What are supernatural beliefs?

Fictitious explanations of the unknown.

Quote from: "KebertX"Are there extraterrestrials?

Probably yes.

Quote from: "KebertX"Who are they?

What a fcking stupid question.

Quote from: "KebertX"Do psychics work, and if you are religious, are they allowed?

There is insufficient rigorous research to be able to answer this question.

Quote from: "KebertX"Where do the voices in our heads come from?

Our heads.

Quote from: "KebertX"Will there be a doomsday?

Insufficient data.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the greatest danger facing man’s existence?

Mankind.

Quote from: "KebertX"How do we stop conflict?

All commit suicide, given any two humans there will always be conflict.

Quote from: "KebertX"Should different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife?

One can not preserve a culture only it's external tribal manifestations. The act of preservation destroys the culture.

Quote from: "KebertX"Should political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy?

Probably not.

~

Quote from: "KebertX"I obviously don't expect people to answer all of these, just have fun with the philosophical questions of life!

There you go. I may answer one resulting question if I feel in a good mood.

Should I copy these to my blog and bold the ones that apply to me??? And then tell 10 of my friends that if they do it, the person they have a crush on will kiss them in 10 days??!?!  :typehappy:  :|

Wow, I know this was well meant, but please don't just copy and paste giant pieces of text like this (especially without credit to the original author(s))!

The only thing worse than having to read an opening post like this is when someone actually takes the time to quote it ALL and post responses to it (no names mentioned!).
 

This post just made me barf a little in my mouth and decide to simply move on.

Well I started and just kept going  

Actually I think the OP should answer all the questions  

Quote from: "Tank"Religion is institutionalised superstition, science is institutionalised curiosity.

Awesome.  Tank - I'm swiping this for my sig line.

Quote from: "The Black Jester"

Quote from: "Tank"Religion is institutionalised superstition, science is institutionalised curiosity.

Awesome.  Tank - I'm swiping this for my sig line.

You're welcome  

Quote from: "Tank"Well I started and just kept going  

Well, I'm secretly impressed. I just didn't have the attention span to fo through them all and give serious answers. Lol!

Quote from: "McQ"

Quote from: "Tank"Well I started and just kept going  

Well, I'm secretly impressed. I just didn't have the attention span to fo through them all and give serious answers. Lol!

Serves me right for not reading the whole post first (https://www.happyatheistforum.com/forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimg34.imageshack.us%2Fimg34%2F2438%2Fheheoc.gif&hash=50cf1131f6316b9f48965cce1bfe1877dc8f90e7)

That made an interesting read.

Tried to make it a bit different from your answer

Quote from: "Asmodean"Tried to make it a bit different from your answer :P

Quote from: "Tank"

Quote from: "Asmodean"Tried to make it a bit different from your answer :P

Never said "improve" Said "different"

Quote from: "Asmodean"

Quote from: "Tank"

Quote from: "Asmodean"Tried to make it a bit different from your answer :P

Never said "improve" Said "different"

Well I thought some were better, they were sometimes longer.

Quote from: "Tank"Well I thought some were better, they were sometimes longer.

Here and there Didn't bother with writing a book over this though

Quote from: "Tank"Actually I think the OP should answer all the questions  :bananacolor: )

~ What’s the difference between religion and science?
Religion is asserted as intrinsically true.  Science is only determined to be true after we can externally determine that it's true.  Science requires evidence, Religious faith not only lacks evidence, its independence from evidence is its pride and joy, shouted from the rooftops.

~ Can a religion change with society?
Of course.  Look how Muslims gave up slavery, Hindus gave up the caste system, and Christians gave up Witch Burning.

~ Was man created or did he evolve?
Evolve.  This is pretty much apparent based on everything we know from science.

~ Is there a God?
Depends on how you define God.  If God is real in your mind, it's as real as it needs to be, regardless of external existence.  The problem is when God is asserted onto society based on no external evidence.  In terms of external existence, Probably Not.  I believe in God, only I spell it 'nature'.

~What is the definition of God?
An Invisible man in the sky.  Or an Omnipresent, Omniscient, Omnipotent, Benevolent, Creator-Being. OR an omnipresent external spiritual force.  It depends on your religion, the first 2 are impossible, the last is very unlikely.

~What gives you certainty in your belief?
Observation.  What can be shown to me to be true, I will gain more certainty in my belief of that thing.

~ How do you deal with doubt?
Channel my doubt into a question, search out an answer to the question, assimilate my doubts into a new source of information.

~ Who created God?
The imagination.  Or if you prefer the definition: " omnipresent external spiritual force." The Big Bang.  The same source of all other matter and energy in the universe.

~Is God male or female?
Neither.  What a ridiculous question!

~ What does God need from us?
Nothing.  There is no personal god. It creates a paradox.

~ Who is/are the Messiah(s)?
Deepok Chopra.  JK, Messiah is sort of a retarded concept. Based on the Christian concept of Original sin, implying that Humans need a savior.

~ Who is the Devil?
A work of fiction adapted from a Pagan God and turned into an entity of pure evil in order to justify a genocide.  There is no Devil, and if God is the opposite of the Devil, then there is no God either.

~ What is faith?
Faith is a truth that appeals to your emotions, and not your intellect.  Something you feel inside you, in terms of spirituality if you have faith in something, it is true enough for YOU, but not necessarily external reality.  Faith can be placed in things that are not real, like America winning the World Cup.  That is why fact is more reliable than faith.  

~ What is a fact?
Facts are truths that appeal to the intellect.

~ How can we tell which is which?
A lot of people surprisingly cannot.  Facts are externally verifiable, faith must be placed in things that are only inside your mind.

~ What is truth?
A lie is a lie even if everyone believes it. The truth is the truth even if nobody believes it.  Truth is reality as it really is, regardless of what anyone thinks about it.  People are generally incapable of seeing the pure truth of reality because of out limited perception of the universe.  For example: Tomatoes are not red. They are every color BUT red, red is the photon wavelength that is bounced back off of the tomato.

~How do we determine truth?
We seek an empirical answer.  Math, and the scientific methods are the two basic ways humans deduct truth from given premises.  Once again, our faith in something as true must come from tested observations.

~ Which truth is right?
In terms of spirituality: All of them.  In terms of religion: None of them.  In terms of reality: Only one.

~ Is the holy-book(s) literally true?
Sorry, stupid question!  ABSOLUTELY NOT!!!

~ What is the origin of the holy book(s)?
People out in the desert were enamored by faith in their invisible sky man, and wrote fictional fables about him.  The bible is a collection of desert scribblings that were compiled together from multiple sources.  The Qu'ran was the ramblings of a seemingly crazy man who wanted to explain God.

~ How do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.?
We have reason.  All those people who say that they get their morals from a Holy Book, actually get their morals from reasoning, just like everyone else.  Virtually no one gets their morals from Holy Books, because they know slavery and stoning and genocide are wrong.  They know this because they have the ability to reason, and that makes the evil things in scriptures tolerable. YOU DON'T ACCEPT UNACCEPTABLE BEHAVIORS LIKE SLAVERY INCEST AND MURDER JUST BECAUSE PEOPLE THOUGHT THEY WERE OKAY 2000 YEARS AGO!

~ Can we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest?
If we don't, then we are not reasonable.  See above.

~ What is morality?
To me, morality is just the acceptance of the simple concept that people should not harm one another.  Blasphemy and Homosexuality are not immoral, they don't harm anybody.  Murder and theft are immoral, they harm people.

~ Is there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures?
See above.  Just about every society agrees with the concept that the entire society does better when individuals don't harm each other.

~ Where does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from?
Most likely, evolution.  Under the conditions of having to live in a social environment, homo sapiens developed a natural inclination towards morality.  A part of the brain that tells you instinctively to conform to societies rules.  Natural Selection favors good Karma, your existence is more endowed with positivity when you produce positive energy.

~ Is altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity?
STUPID QUESTION.  The obvious answer is yes.

~ What is sin?
Anything immoral.  In the Judaio-Christian sense, sin is something that violates the word of God, which, of course does not really come from an invisible man in the sky, but controlling primitive people who found Sin an easy way to scare lower classes into falling into line.

~ What is the punishment for sin?
You produce energy, you receive the same sort of energy back.  You do something immoral, and create a negativity deficit, which will naturally come back to you to retain an equilibrium of neutral Karma.  That's just what I tend to think, in the real world, the punishment for most "sins" are prison in this society.

~ Is thought the same as deed?
Your thoughts become your actions. Your actions become your character.  Your character becomes your destiny.  Thoughts aren't the same as DOING something, because they only have secondary effects in the real world.

~ Does God want to test us? Why?
No. The short answer would be, because he's not real, the longer answer would mention that God would have to be an impersonal force if he were real, and impersonal forces don't care about "testing" you.

~ Should a person have sex before marriage?
Why not? Consenting adults can do whatever they want.

~ Is masturbation a sin?
STUPID QUESTION.  Sexual gratification is not immoral.

~ What determines sexual orientation?
A combination of genetic and environmental factors.

~ Why is God interested in our sexual behavior?
Because the people who wrote those parts of the bible were concerned with controlling people.

~ Should women be treated differently than men?
Equal rights, liberties, and opportunities.  But women are men ARE different, you may want to adjust your behavior accordingly (in a non-discriminatory way).

~ Do we have free will?
Debatable. Chaos Theory vs. Multiverse Theory.  We have choices, but our choices are a product of the EXACT situation that leads up to them.  All sentient beings can make decisions, but it may or may not be physically possible for our decisions to be different than what they end up being.  Possibly branching off into infinite alternate universes, each of which having different EXACT configuration of particles in the universe, leading to an infinite number of differences in different universes.  Including different decisions made by different people.  There's actually quite a bit of quantum physics supporting this.  On the other hand, universes may not differentiate, in which case there is one reality, and there is only one future, and our decisions always will be what they end up being.

~ Is everything predetermined?
Still debatable.  In a way they are determined by configurations of particles in the universe, but (See above) there may be an infinite number of alternate possibilities for the future.

~ What entity predetermines fate or destiny?
No entity.  The laws of physics and natural forces of the universe.

~ Why is there suffering?
Buddhist philosophy says suffering is a product of attachment.  When I read these things, it seems to make sense, we suffer as an eventuality of life, because we are attached to things that provide us happiness, and suffer when we lose these things, (Money, Beliefs, Health, Love, Life, etc.)

~ What is best path to happiness?
Detachment.  When we truly accept the impermanence of things that make us happy, we become free of the attachment that makes us suffer.  You need to KNOW, not fear, KNOW that you are going to die someday, before you can truly start living.

~Does God intercede in human tragedies?
No, God only exists inside individual people's minds.

~Does prayer work?
No, Prayer is only a thought.  The thought must become an action before it has a significant effect.

~If so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters?
Because God is either not externally existent, of is completely impersonal.

~ If not, why pray?
It makes you feel good to persist in the delusion that a loving being is hearing your problems, but it won't accomplish anything noticeable 99.9999999999999999999...9% of the time

~ Does meditation work?
Yes.

~ How does meditation work?
The mind controls the body, meditation is the practice of calming and controlling the mind.  I can personally attest to the fact that it works like a charm.

~ What is a soul?
A lifeforms supposed spiritual energy.

~ Do animals have souls?
Only when they can create their soul.  You need to create these spiritual things in your own mind.

~ Does a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body?
No.

~ If a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up?
Intangibility.  How convenient for people who don't want their beliefs tested.  Once again, it's only real if it exists in your mind.  Every being has an entire spiritual universe, which does not have any external reality.  Each being creates their spiritual reality on it's own.  In terms of external reality, you might say that a soul is imaginary.

~ What purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it?
STUPID QUESTION! Souls can't feel, and they can't really exist without a mind, and a mind is a product of the synapses in your brain.

~ Is there an Afterlife?
Life continues, in the sense that it begets more life.  Your Karma is recycled back into the universe, like a drop of water returning to the ocean.  Everything you would define yourself as dies when you die, but you leave an incredibly minute imprint on the universe, and that same energy is responsible for the existence of other lifeforms

~ Where is it, where do we go after death?
See above.  Your energy is dispersed into the universe.

~ Why do we need an afterlife?
We don't. It's an inevitability that we die, and the universe continues to exist after we die.  If by "Afterlife" the question is referring to Heaven.  That's just not real.

~ When does life begin?
When something fits the criteria of life.  Reproduction, Metabolism, Homeostasis, Growth, and Response to Stimuli.  Life is a scientific term, it has earned its scientific definition.

~ When should abortion be allowed?
When the "baby" is unable to survive outside the womb, or the health of the mother is impeded by the fetus.

~ Is it ever appropriate to kill another person?
Two words: Adolf Hitler.

~ What are supernatural beliefs?
Belief in anything that cannot be examined in a scientific manner.

~ Are there extraterrestrials?
Probably, it's a big universe.

~Who are they?
That is the stupidest question on this survey. Obviously we don't know.

~ Do psychics work, and if you are religious, are they allowed?
Psychics are either frauds, or deluded individuals who actually think they know the future.  I'm not religious, but they are not allowed.  Psychics give people false hope, spread lies, and hold back society.

~ Where do the voices in our heads come from?
It's called intuition.  Or Delusional Schizophrenia.

~ Will there be a doomsday?
Only if major world religions continue to self fulfill the prophecies in their Holy Books.

~ What is the greatest danger facing man’s existence?
Our own destructiveness.

~ How do we stop conflict?
See "How can we improve humanity?"  Putting an end to conflicts through education, and mutual concern for one another.

~ Should different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife?
Preserved. We are able to rise above our differences.  I have enough faith in humanity to say that.

~ Should political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy?
Not if their expecting the deity to help in any way.  Look inside yourself for an answer, don't bother with the sky.

~

Oh my god, I didn't realize how long this was.  Once again, I didn't mean for people to try to answer them one by one.  Here are my answers, enjoy...?

Why do we exist? We as a species exsist due to a series of biological changes known as evolution.
What is the best thing about existing?Awareness
What is our purpose?Each individual has to give their life it's own purpose. I try to make my purpose loving people and helping them when i have the ability
Is the world a better place for having had humans in it?No, but it has the potential to be
How can we improve humanity?We need to learn empathy and that empathy needs to drive us to act
What is the best advice or philosophy for living?Enjoy the beauty in life because it doesnt last long and help your fellow human beings be able to do the same

What is religion? A man made system of beliefs often without foundation in reality
Why are there multiple religions?Because there are so many people with so many fears and desires
Should religions be challenged?always
Is skepticism a good thing?yes,but cynicism is not
Why do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged?because theyve invested so much in them
Which religion is right?If there were a right religion there'd be no religon just reality
Can all religions be correct?No they often say they are the only truth
What does fear have to do with belief?fear is the method used by many religions to control their followers' thoughts
Do we have a need to believe in something?yes, but its best believe in ( rather know )things that are real like love and compassion
What is spirituality?in reality probably a deep emotional connection happening in the mind


Can religion and science coexist?If you are good at compartmentalization

What is truth?verifiable knowledge
How do we determine truth?we investigate and try to set aside bias
Which truth is right?The one who has the correct facts
Is the holy-book(s) literally true?Ive yet to find one
What is the origin of the holy book(s)?humans
How do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.?We shouldnt i spent too much of my life doing just that
Can we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest?People do it all of the time but its intellectually dishonest

What is morality?according to stanford encyclopedia of philosophy  1.descriptively to refer to a code of conduct put forward by a society or,
a.some other group, such as a religion, or
b.accepted by an individual for her own behavior or
2.normatively to refer to a code of conduct that, given specified conditions, would be put forward by all rational persons.I prefer the second definition
Is there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures?In general treat others with kindness
Where does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from?We have evolved morality as a means to survive as a species since we live in family groups and larger societal groups
Is altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity?of course

What is sin?an arbitrary concept imposed by various religions
What is the punishment for sin? depends on the religion
Is thought the same as deed?no
Does God want to test us? Why?


Should a person have sex before marriage?depends on the individual and their circumstances
Is masturbation a sin?No its recreation
What determines sexual orientation?biology and socialization
Why is God interested in our sexual behavior?
Should women be treated differently than men?people should be treated as individuals on their merits

Do we have free will?to a certain extent but its not god given
Is everything predetermined?no
What entity predetermines fate or destiny?our choices and the choices of others determine our lives

Why is there suffering?some people are lack empathy , some people hurt others, and there are diseases and natural cirsumstances that cause it
What is best path to happiness?im trying to find that out now
Does God intercede in human tragedies?clearly not

Does prayer work?in that it can relax a believer to a certain degree yes
If so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters?it only works in circumstances where a person needs to be calm and prayer can calm people it works the way deep breathing does
If not, why pray?i dont
Does meditation work?in the same way prayer does
How does meditation work?


What is a soul?i dont know i think its a poetic name for the mind
Do animals have souls?
Does a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body?no
If a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up?
What purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it?

Is there an Afterlife?probably not
Where is it, where do we go after death?
Why do we need an afterlife?we dont it takes away meaning for our current one

When does life begin?acording to jayz when the church ends... where abortion is concerned the argument is silly because even a sperm cell or an egg is life skin cells are life bacteria are life
When should abortion be allowed? yes but not in the third term unless a womans life is in danger
Is it ever appropriate to kill another person?to protect yourself or loved ones

Where do the voices in our heads come from?I only have one voice in my head and that is me it comes from my mind im just not sure where in my mind

Will there be a doomsday?If we dont take care of our environment or an asteroid hits the earth
What is the greatest danger facing man’s existence?other humans
How do we stop conflict?thats the million dollar question
Should different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife?Cultural identity should be preserved unless that culture is a threat to other people
Should political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy?no they should have reason

Why do we exist? Because we think.  

What is the best thing about existing? Being able to think!

What is our purpose? To make a purpose.

Is the world a better place for having had humans in it? No.

How can we improve humanity? Make me Supreme Dictator.

What is the best advice or philosophy for living? Amor fati.

What is religion? Highly important nonsense.

This is all I could take. Sorry....

Why do we exist? Because we do, if we didn't then it doesn't matter. If we can never know, then there's no point in getting all mind hurty over it, and if can... Well I still don't care, it would be interesting to know however.
What is the best thing about existing? Oh, the usual mushy things.
What is our purpose? Don't know, don't care to know.
Is the world a better place for having had humans in it? Yes, and no. About even.
How can we improve humanity? Spread a little love, if nothign else it couldn't hurt... Much.

What is the best advice or philosophy for living? "Doesn't matter what the press says. Doesn't matter what the politicians or the mobs say. Doesn't matter if the whole country decides that something wrong is something right. This nation was founded on one principle above all else: the requirement that we stand up for what we believe, no matter the odds or the consequences. When the mob and the press and the whole world tell you to move, your job is to plant yourself like a tree beside the river of truth, and tell the whole world â€" No, you move." - Captain Frikken America

What is religion? A personal belief regarding the nature/existence of the divine.
Why are there multiple religions? People. Are. People. We can't agree on ANYTHING.
Should religions be challenged? Yes, but respectivly.
Is skepticism a good thing? Yes.
Why do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged? As a general rulle people are arrogant, hubristic, and stubborn.
Which religion is right? All of them, as well as none of them.
Can all religions be correct? See the above.
What does fear have to do with belief? Certain people use their belief as a security blanket, these kinds of people see their god as the ultimate authority figure.
Do we have a need to believe in something? Yes, because it's a fundamental part of humanity to believe.
What is spirituality? It's a lot of things, and nothing in particular.


Can religion and science coexist? I'd like to think so.
What’s the difference between religion and science? Science is written in pencil, and religion is made of clay. Metaphorically speaking.
Can a religion change with society? Yes.
Was man created or did he evolve? Can't it be both?

Is there a God? Yes and no.
What is the definition of God? A being, or at least a thingie that makes... stuff happen.
What gives you certainty in your belief? Apathy.
How do you deal with doubt? Hmm, it's not really an issue with me. MY beliefs are constantly evolving,a nd adapting to new circumstances.
Who created God? God was created much the same way we were, natural phenomena caused a small weak thign to come into existence which evolved into something much greater. That's my current theory.
Is God male or female? Both, and neither.
What does God need from us? Nothing really, I don't think.
Who is/are the Messiah(s)? N/A
Who is the Devil? We are.  

What is faith? A song by Sharon Knight.
What is a fact? A Japanese band.
How can we tell which is which? Sharon is more celtic inspired, and Fact has a more post-hardcore proggy sound.

What is truth? Fortitude, and sincerity in action, character, and utterance.
How do we determine truth? Hmm, you know it when you see it. It's like music that way.
Which truth is right? All of them, none of them... It really depends.

Is the holy-book(s) literally true? If you're talking about the bible probably not, given it's inconsistancy. If you're talkign about my Scott Cunningham books, then yes for the most part.
What is the origin of the holy book(s)? Long dead cultists, and the sadly also dead Scott Cunningham.
How do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.? Negatively, I hope.
Can we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest? That's what most people do anyway.

What is morality? Conformity to ideals of righteous human conduct.
Is there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures? Not really... Right, and Wrong are very subject and vary form locale to locale.
Where does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from? Our brain, and our heart.
Is altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity? Both are possible for all people, unforunately.

What is sin? A Judeo-Christian concept.
What is the punishment for sin? I'm told burning for all eternity.
Is thought the same as deed? No, they are very different things.
Does God want to test us? Why? I'm pretty sure it doesn't care.

Should a person have sex before marriage? If they want to, and do it safely and concentually then I don't care one way or the other.
Is masturbation a sin? Possibly, I'll aks a Christian... Yes.
What determines sexual orientation? Lots of things. Probably a combination of one's genes, and upbriing.
Why is God interested in our sexual behavior? It most likely isn't, I can't imagine why it would be... Unless he likes to watch.
Should women be treated differently than men? Yes, and no.

Do we have free will? Yes, and no.
Is everything predetermined? Maybe, maybe not... It doens't matter.
What entity predetermines fate or destiny? I assume Destiny.

Why is there suffering? So that there may be joy.
What is best path to happiness? That depends on the person, and the situation.
Does God intercede in human tragedies? Sometimes, usually not.

Does prayer work? To a certain extent.
If so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters? It allows us to reap what we sow, and because of balance.
If not, why pray? In the off chance that it might.
Does meditation work? Yes.
How does meditation work? By focus, and relaxation.

What is a soul? An intangible essence within, and about all things.
Do animals have souls? Yes.
Does a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body? Yes, and no.
If a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up?They have the echoes of our memories, the essense holds the echoes all memories.
What purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it? for thinking of course! Which is why ghosts have such a hard time oving on, they've lost their way without their brain. The only have the echo of it.

Is there an Afterlife? I'd like to think so.
Where is it, where do we go after death? Probably a higher plane of existance.
Why do we need an afterlife? We don't, it just is.

When does life begin? It doesn't, it always is and always will be... Or at least that's my take on it.
When should abortion be allowed? When it would alleviate suffering.
Is it ever appropriate to kill another person? Sometimes.

What are supernatural beliefs? The belief in things which are not yet explained by science.
Are there extraterrestrials? Yes.
Who are they? They are who they are.
Do psychics work, and if you are religious, are they allowed? Some do, most don't.
Where do the voices in our heads come from? Our brains mostly.

Will there be a doomsday? I don't know, and I don't want to know.
What is the greatest danger facing man’s existence? There's quite a lot of them.
How do we stop conflict? We don't, unless you want to stop a lot of other things as well.
Should different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife? People will always find ways to divide themselves, I say we keep waht we have now because I can understand it.
Should political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy? No.

These are ten questions?  

I wonder how a god would answer the first question. Why would a god exist?

Quote from: "KebertX"Why do we exist? I Think we're lucky to exist, and we do because that's just how things are. It just happened.

What is the best thing about existing?Just that, existing.

What is our purpose?Uhm, define purpose. I believe MY purpose is to better the human race.

Is the world a better place for having had humans in it?Of course, We've accomplished so much.

How can we improve humanity?By focusing on reality, and using that to understand why we're here and why we should

What is the best advice or philosophy for living?I can't sum that up in one sentance.



What is religion?I believe religion is a form of government. If you don't have control, god does, and you use him to strike fear into the hearts of wrong-doers.

Why are there multiple religions?Because of what I said above.

Should religions be challenged?YES!

Is skepticism a good thing?If you don't have skepticism, your not human.

Why do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged?because they were raised knowing their belief as truth, and when someone says its not, it angers them.

Which religion is right?Of course none of the are right. it's silly to believe one religion over another.

Can all religions be correct?No, because the Hebrew God says, you shall have no other gods before me, sooooo.

What does fear have to do with belief?YOUR GOING TO HELL IF YOU DO THIS, SO DON'T DO IT! And alot of people will not.

Do we have a need to believe in something?No.

What is spirituality?The believe in spirits... Which is again, silly.

I don't have time right now to do all of them, maybe I'll get around to them later.

Quote from: "Tank"

Quote from: "KebertX"Think of this as a meme.  How do you answer these questions for yourselves?  A lot of Atheists here won't have a problem just shrugging these off, but give them a little thought anyway.  It should be a little fun...


Why do we exist?

Plastic - George Carlin

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the best thing about existing?

cake, video games, sex, junkfood, laughter

Quote from: "KebertX"What is our purpose?

pollination

Quote from: "KebertX"Is the world a better place for having had humans in it?

Nopers. but she's a patient bitch and that's why we love her.

Quote from: "KebertX"can we improve humanity?

yes yes, it all starts with physical fitness and and good nutrition.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the best advice or philosophy for living?

Don't fake laugh too much,         you'll get smile lines early.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is religion?

Santa Clause for adults.

Quote from: "KebertX"Why are there multiple religions?

to make shit fun,
it turns the existence of our species into a game show, to find out which one was right.

Quote from: "KebertX"Should religions be challenged?

no, just removed and anybody that still wants to believe, be killed,........ really dude, we're overpopulating anyway.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is skepticism a good thing?

yes,  

Quote from: "KebertX"Why do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged?

fear - I'll elaborate upon request.

Quote from: "KebertX"Which religion is right?

The Church of the Fonz............ "Can I get a Ayyyyye.... Now sit on it" -peter griffen-

Quote from: "KebertX"Can all religions be correct?

that would kind of fuck up the game show wouldn't it?..... well, wouldn't it!?

Quote from: "KebertX"What does fear have to do with belief?

fear is how they get the young ones.

Quote from: "KebertX"Do we have a need to believe in something?

no

Quote from: "KebertX"What is spirituality?

a code word for closet atheists...... come out the closet you fucking coward.

Quote from: "KebertX"Can religion and science coexist?

isn't that happening right now, if have they ended all science classes and burned the books since my graduation?

Quote from: "KebertX"What’s the difference between religion and science?

science is always ready to admit something went wrong and they're ready to try something new.
RELIGION HAS BEEN WRONG FOR FUCKING EVER, WE EVEN FOUND OUT EARTH WASN'T FLAT AND PEOPLE ARE STILL RELIGIOUS.                 FUCK!!!!!!!!!

Quote from: "KebertX"Can a religion change with society?

gee willikers...... well, let's see.  Do they still use the same book?

Quote from: "KebertX"Was man created or did he evolve?

evolved............ until around 1998-2005 we began to de-evolve, especially what used to be the american man.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is there a God?

no

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the definition of God?

the thing that i just said doesn't exist..

Quote from: "KebertX"What gives you certainty in your belief?

but if I don't believe, then I don't have a belief........ -question fail-.

Quote from: "KebertX"How do you deal with doubt?

Push the coffee table over and dance to one of my Britney Spears playlists.
 

Quote from: "KebertX"Who created God?

Stupid questions activate my sense of humor.......I'm trying not to be too goofy here.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is God male or female?

tranny

Quote from: "KebertX"What does God need from us?

hormone pills.

Quote from: "KebertX"Who is/are the Messiah(s)?

Vanilla Ice, Marky Mark and Paula Abdule

Quote from: "KebertX"Who is the Devil?

My sister, she makes friends with all my exes? W .T.F!?!?

Quote from: "KebertX"What is faith?

just a fancy pants way to say "belief"   ie "I believe in you timmy"  - "I have faith in you timmy"

Quote from: "KebertX"What is a fact?

Something that can be independently and repeatedly determined.

Quote from: "KebertX"How can we tell which is which?

faith and facts aren't even....... like really, the two don't correlate to be compared

Quote from: "KebertX"What is truth?

when i tell you something i really believe.
like I might say Ju Ju Bee is a cute chick, and I'd be telling the truth because Ju Ju Bee may have foold me, but then I'll find out that Ju Ju Bee is a drag performer,so  I would go back and  say Ju Ju Bee is a dude.
kind of like science.

Quote from: "KebertX"How do we determine truth?

3rd party gossip.

Quote from: "KebertX"Which truth is right?

the one that's not left, some of these questions are just filler, but I'm having fun.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is the holy-book(s) literally true?

uuummmmmmm......... talking snake?

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the origin of the holy book(s)?

The holy magazine, and before that, the holy newsletter, and before that, the holy pamphlet.

Quote from: "KebertX"How do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.?

because the stories in it are more amusing than season 2 of desperate housewives.
season 2 was fucking crazy.

Quote from: "KebertX"Can we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest?

yes, but we can't make it our own, we have share, sharing is caring homey.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is morality?

what religion was supposed to be and has yet to achieve.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures?

there's a few. it seems that rape, pedo's, "snitching", talking sideways to your parents.

these and some others pretty much universally frowned upon.

Quote from: "KebertX"Where does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from?

for myself, childhood, remembering what was interesting, frustrating, challenging from then.
makes me want to be a better adult for the next generation coming.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity?

it's the only way. god tells his little friends down here to do toooooooooooo much foul shit.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is sin?

a monosyllabic bible word.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the punishment for sin?

the holy newsletter says death.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is thought the same as deed?

nigga what?

Quote from: "KebertX"Does God want to test us? Why?

no, he knows better, he made us in his image, so he already knows we'll cheat on it.
that's how i got into college.

Quote from: "KebertX"Should a person have sex before marriage?

hell yes, what if you get married and find out you're not sexually compatible with the person you chose?!

Quote from: "KebertX"Is masturbation a sin?

only if you use the left hand on a tuesday.

Quote from: "KebertX"What determines sexual orientation?

nature, (these are just my high ass thoughts),
but I think nature makes homos so we won't overpopulate as our species is dominate and damaging on this planet.
but because of religion, a lot lot lot of homos try not to be that or whatever, so because of religion which says "be fruitful and multiply"
we won't just do what nature does so we just keep making more people, taking up more space, using up more shit and increasing the big ass mess we already made.

Quote from: "KebertX"Why is God interested in our sexual behavior?

he's competitive.
you gotta realize this god dude is the guy who fucked another dudes virgin wife,
got her pregged up,
made her keep it, and then made the other dude raise his kid. but wouldn't let him claim him on his taxes.

Quote from: "KebertX"Should women be treated differently than men?

no, women have gone too far with one major thing,
and don't think I'm taking a pro "hitting women" stance, but the behavior of a lot of women is based off the fact that they KNOW they will not get punched in the face for it.

Quote from: "KebertX"Do we have free will?

no

Quote from: "KebertX"Is everything predetermined?

no

Quote from: "KebertX"What entity predetermines fate or destiny?

lord of skittles

Quote from: "KebertX"Why is there suffering?

because we made too many people and not enough food.......... well there's enough food, but not enough money to buy it...........

well, there's enough money to buy it, but one person is allowed to have billions of these dollars, while another person has none.

so I guess I'd say there's suffering because of capitolism.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is best path to happiness?

the endorphins

Quote from: "KebertX"Does God intercede in human tragedies?

question fail

Quote from: "KebertX"Does prayer work?

questions fail

Quote from: "KebertX"If so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters?

okay, i'll play along, it's the Test thing.

Quote from: "KebertX"If not, why pray?

dude I don't so it's another "Question fail"

Quote from: "KebertX"Does meditation work?

I don't think anybody really meditates, I think they just fake it to seem all deep n shit

Quote from: "KebertX"How does meditation work?

dammit.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is a soul?

its what shang tsung takes from you in Mortal Kombat.

Quote from: "KebertX"Do animals have souls?

fuck yea.

Quote from: "KebertX"Does a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body?

thoughts, but not feelings, to a naked soul everything is kind of liquidy, but not in a gross way.

Quote from: "KebertX"If a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up?

white bloodcells and vaginal mucus

Quote from: "KebertX"What purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it?

It keeps the weight of our heads even so our necks can hold them up straight.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is there an Afterlife?

yea nigga, it's call DEATH

Quote from: "KebertX"Where is it, where do we go after death?
Why do we need an afterlife?

We? you mean where do you go after death.

I'm staying in my house.

Quote from: "KebertX"When does life begin?

sound like an abortion question.......... so uuummmmm.

when it's old enough that you can see if it will be productive and innovative or just another dumbfuck taking up space. so you know like 11-13 years old.

Quote from: "KebertX"When should abortion be allowed?

between the condom breaking and 13 years old.

Quote from: "KebertX"Is it ever appropriate to kill another person?

uuuuhh duh yea, whey should we be taxed to keep pedophiles alive in prison, just kill them.

Quote from: "KebertX"What are supernatural beliefs?

the results of too much daydreaming.

Quote from: "KebertX"Are there extraterrestrials?

i don't know, but i love watching alien shows.

Quote from: "KebertX"Who are they?

Audrey 2 and Howard the duck.

Quote from: "KebertX"Do psychics work, and if you are religious, are they allowed?

There is insufficient rigorous research to be able to answer this question.

Quote from: "KebertX"Where do the voices in our heads come from?

there are no voices in our heads, just thoughts. there would have to be......

lungs,
vocal cords,
and british accents to have voices in our heads.

Quote from: "KebertX"Will there be a doomsday?

there already is a doomsday, they're the best hardcore rap group out of nevada.

Quote from: "KebertX"What is the greatest danger facing man’s existence?

selfishness.

Quote from: "KebertX"How do we stop conflict?

All commit suicide, given any two humans there will always be conflict.

Quote from: "KebertX"Should different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife?

no

Quote from: "KebertX"Should political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy?

no
~

Quote from: "KebertX"I obviously don't expect people to answer all of these, just have fun with the philosophical questions of life!

There you go. I may answer one resulting question if I feel in a good mood.

What do you mean by "pollination?"

Why do we exist?
Ultimately I have no clue why anything exists rather than not existing but think there is valid reason to think humans evolved on Earth by natural process and that is why we exist.

What is the best thing about existing?
As opposed to not existing?  

What is our purpose?
Nature seems to dictate that our purpose is to multiply but on an individual basis we can make up our own purpose (including one that doesn't include multiplying).

Is the world a better place for having had humans in it?
The answer to that depends on if one cares more about the state of the Environment or about the welfare of Humans.  I personally like people so I'll say yes it is better off...but I say this knowing it's a completely subjective opinion.

How can we improve humanity?
Control population and figure out a way to get everyone to mind their own business.

What is the best advice or philosophy for living?
If someone isn't bothering you don't make it your business to bother them.

What is religion?
I'll defer to the dictionary: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/religion (http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/religion)
â€"noun
1.a set of beliefs concerning the cause, nature, and purpose of the universe, esp. when considered as the creation of a superhuman agency or agencies, usually involving devotional and ritual observances, and often containing a moral code governing the conduct of human affairs.
2.a specific fundamental set of beliefs and practices generally agreed upon by a number of persons or sects: the Christian religion; the Buddhist religion.
3.the body of persons adhering to a particular set of beliefs and practices: a world council of religions.

Why are there multiple religions?
There are multiple religions because no one knows what they are talking about yet since it is human nature to want to have the answers they do their best to make up a story that seems to fit reality.  Yet as times change and we learn more about reality and as power hungry people learn how to abuse religious followers more religions pop up to fill new needs.

Should religions be challenged?
In appropriate settings, yes.  But not, for example, at work just because you see a co-worker wearing a cross.

Is skepticism a good thing?
Yes, skepticism drives learning and the development of new ideas.  If we were not skeptical then we'd always assume what we are told is true (including lies) and wouldn't have a reason to continue studying the world around us to make sure we still have the best possible grasp of how it works.

Why do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged?
Many people's beliefs are also a core part of their self identity so a challenge to their beliefs is like saying something is wrong with them; or at least is perceived that way.

Which religion is right?
none

Can all religions be correct?
Theoretically they could all be correct if god were real and that god viewed all religions as individual expressions of worship (aka pluralism)....but realistically no they can't all be correct.

What does fear have to do with belief?
Other than fear being a common tactic for making people fear questioning a religious belief I'm not sure what the question is referring to.

Do we have a need to believe in something?
Practically all people have beliefs but not all people have religious beliefs.  I don't find a reason to think that the average person has a biological need to believe in a higher power.

What is spirituality?
A word that doesn't seem to be used in the same way by any two people.

Can religion and science coexist?
yes...but not in all cases since some religions are more accepting of reality than others.

What’s the difference between religion and science?
  one uses blind faith and the other actually investigates reality to determine truth

Can a religion change with society?
Obviously it can as it has over time and the change is historically documented.

Was man created or did he evolve?
evolve

Is there a God?
no

What is the definition of God?
being that created all that exists

What gives you certainty in your belief?
I don't consider my beliefs to be certain.

How do you deal with doubt?
Explore it.

Who created God?
man

Is God male or female?
if there is a god I double it would have a need for reproductive parts

What does God need from us?
n/a

Who is/are the Messiah(s)?
n/a

Who is the Devil?
n/a

What is faith?
belief in something without proof/reason

What is a fact?
something that can be objectively verified

How can we tell which is which?
by using their definitions....

What is truth?
What someone is doing when they are conveying information they believe to be a fact.

How do we determine truth?
see definition of fact

Which truth is right?
see definition of fact

Is the holy-book(s) literally true?
no

What is the origin of the holy book(s)?
storytellers

How do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.?
Compartmentalization and bigotry.

Can we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest?
One can...but it kinda defeats any claim to religion being fact and not just something people make up.

What is morality?
A set of codes/actions humans follow in order to interact with each other peacefully.

Is there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures?
Not really, but generally it seems to be universally considered immoral to kill members of your own group unless they have broken a moral code.

Where does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from?
As with other social animals, our morality was selected for over time because working together was more beneficial than working as individuals.

Is altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity?
Yes.


***got bored at this point so I might answer the rest later***

Quote from: "Byronazriel"What do you mean by "pollination?"

moving seeds around to keep plant life going.

but..........

we over-bred our species and fucked up natures plan.

that's just one thought though.

Quote from: "TheWilliam"we over-bred our species and fucked up natures plan.

Kinda' like an overbred virus fucks up its host.

Quote from: "TheWilliam"

Quote from: "KebertX"When should abortion be allowed?

between the condom breaking and 13 years old.

Pure gold, this one. I literally spit out my drink.

Quote from: "KebertX"Why do we exist?

Circular question. It assumes that there is a reason, and there's no good reason to suppose that there is.

QuoteWhat is the best thing about existing?

Cannabis.

QuoteWhat is our purpose?

More question begging. Assumes a purpose.

QuoteIs the world a better place for having had humans in it?

You'd have to ask the world (and I don't mean the people in it). I can only give an extremely subjective answer.

QuoteHow can we improve humanity?

That's an expansive question. Eradicating the god meme would be a good start.

Quote-What is the best advice or philosophy for living?

The golden rule.

QuoteWhat is religion?

An attempt to replace ignorance, and an unsuccessful one at that.

QuoteWhy are there multiple religions?

Because people the world over have had several attempts to replace their ignorance, and people become entrenched in their pet fantasies.

QuoteShould religions be challenged?

Everything should be challenged, including this very response.

QuoteIs skepticism a good thing?

Yep.

QuoteWhy do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged?

Because they can't separate themselves from their ideas, especially when those ideas have been inculcated in them by people they had every reason to trust.

QuoteWhich religion is right?

Non of them.

QuoteCan all religions be correct?

Nope.

QuoteWhat does fear have to do with belief?

That's a difficult question. For some, I suspect it is the motivator. For others, it's how they maintain their grip on the weak of thought and the credulous.

QuoteDo we have a need to believe in something?

Not really.

QuoteWhat is spirituality?

Good question. I've been asking that of the credulous for as long as I can remember, because they're always banging on about it. None have ever given a satisfactory answer, though.

QuoteCan religion and science coexist?

Not really. Sure, there are scientists, even excellent ones, who have silly beliefs, but when you apply scientific principles to your beliefs, which any really good scientist should do with everything, the beliefs don't stack up.

QuoteWhat’s the difference between religion and science?

One pays attention to reality, while the other invents one or attempts to define it into existence.

QuoteCan a religion change with society?

Of course. They have to, or they won't survive. This, of course, shows that the holy books are simply wrong.

QuoteWas man created or did he evolve?

He evolved.

QuoteIs there a God?

You have this question and the next one the wrong way around. You can't answer this question until the other is answered. The capitalisation betrays something, though. Certainly, none of the gods so far presented by the credulous exist, but that doesn't rule out some entity that we would describe as a deity, though. I seriously doubt it, though. Occam's Razor rules.

QuoteWhat is the definition of God?

See above.

QuoteWhat gives you certainty in your belief?

I possess neither.

QuoteHow do you deal with doubt?

I embrace it.

QuoteWho created God?
Is God male or female?
What does God need from us?
Who is/are the Messiah(s)?
Who is the Devil?

All answered already above.

QuoteWhat is faith?

I'll give the definition given by the famous blue flutterby, because it's my favourite:

Faith is the uncritical acceptance of blind assertions.

QuoteWhat is a fact?

It is something that is categorically true.

QuoteHow can we tell which is which?

By paying attention to reality.

QuoteWhat is truth?

See above.

QuoteHow do we determine truth?

See above.

QuoteWhich truth is right?

The one which is true.

QuoteIs the holy-book(s) literally true?

No, not literally or otherwise.

QuoteWhat is the origin of the holy book(s)?

Which ones?

QuoteHow do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.?

We don't, we villify it, and ridicule it, and use any other means at our disposal to show it for what it is.

QuoteCan we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest?

You'd have to ask somebody who believes, but it certainly seems so. Not only that, they will wrap themselves in apologetic pretzels justifying their decisions in this regard.

QuoteWhat is morality?

It is that which allows us to function as social animals.

QuoteIs there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures?

Nope, because what allows us to function as social animals is dependent on cultural norms, which vary from place to place and society to society.

QuoteWhere does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from?

Our evolutionary past. I'd be happy to come back and expand on this, but any good book about evolution will cover it.

QuoteIs altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity?

I don't think altruism is possible at all. Every time you open your mouth it's for personal gain, in one form or another.

QuoteWhat is sin?

A made-up concept meant to convey disobedience to equally made-up entities.

QuoteWhat is the punishment for sin?

Cheeseburgers?

QuoteIs thought the same as deed?

Not yet.

QuoteDoes God want to test us? Why?

See above re: magic man's existence.

QuoteShould a person have sex before marriage?

I certainly hope so, since I have several children and I'm not married.

QuoteIs masturbation a sin?

No, it's a necessity.

QuoteWhat determines sexual orientation?

The jury is still out on that one.

QuoteWhy is God interested in our sexual behavior?

He isn't, his idiot followers are, probably because they aren't getting any.

QuoteShould women be treated differently than men?

That's difficult, but only because you put it in the sex section. I certainly treat women differently than men in that respect, but otherwise, no.

QuoteDo we have free will?

I highly doubt it. Our decisions are influenced by all kinds of things that we don't remotely understand.

QuoteIs everything predetermined?

Definitely not. That has been ruled out by paying attention to reality.

QuoteWhat entity predetermines fate or destiny?

See above.

QuoteWhy is there suffering?

A reason again? 'How' is always a better question than 'why', not least because there's almost always a valid answer to the latter, and rarely to the former.

QuoteWhat is best path to happiness?

Acceptance of life as it is.

QuoteDoes God intercede in human tragedies?

See above.

QuoteDoes prayer work?

That depends on what you want from it. If you simply want people to know that you give a shit, sure. Beyond that, no.

QuoteIf so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters?
If not, why pray?

See above.

QuoteDoes meditation work?
How does meditation work?

Yes, by calming the mind. There are other means, of course.

QuoteWhat is a soul?

A made-up entity tha... you get the picture.

QuoteDo animals have souls?
Does a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body?
If a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up?
What purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it?

See above.

QuoteIs there an Afterlife?

Almost certainly not.

QuoteWhere is it, where do we go after death?

Into the ground or up in smoke, for the most part.

QuoteWhy do we need an afterlife?

We don't. Indeed, I can think of nothing worse. It's brevity is one of the joys of life.

QuoteWhen does life begin?

Good luck getting a robust answer to that one.

QuoteWhen should abortion be allowed?

Before the formation of the nervous system.

QuoteIs it ever appropriate to kill another person?

Oooh, a proper question!

I used to think the answer was invariably no, but Saddam gave me pause for thought. Once captured, keeping him imprisoned would have made him a target for whackos, both trying to free him and trying to kill him. I think that removing him from the equation was probably the best move for all.

QuoteWhat are supernatural beliefs?

???

QuoteAre there extraterrestrials?

Almost certainly.

QuoteWho are they?

Entities that live outside Earth's biosphere.

QuoteDo psychics work, and if you are religious, are they allowed?

No, they're charlatans. As for the latter part, I don't see why not, since religious leaders come under the same umbrella.

QuoteWhere do the voices in our heads come from?

Inside our heads. Our brains are virtual reality machines par excellence.

QuoteWill there be a doomsday?

Define doomsday.

QuoteWhat is the greatest danger facing man’s existence?

Bolide impact. I wrote an article about this for another forum (http://forum.richarddawkins.net/viewtopic.php?p=2743553#p2743553).

QuoteHow do we stop conflict?

By growing up.

QuoteShould different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife?

I think there is a balance between the two. Cultural heritage is good, but not at the cost of progress.

QuoteShould political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy?

Definitely not.

You say credulous a lot, is that your word of the day?

Mine's malacissation.

Quote from: "Byronazriel"You say credulous a lot, is that your word of the day?

No, it's my word for credulous people. Would you prefer gullible?

I use many words often, and some more than others.

Why do we exist?  - because our parents had sex
What is the best thing about existing? - sex, drugs and rock 'n roll
What is our purpose?  - is there one?
Is the world a better place for having had humans in it? - you should ask the world. Probably it doesn't give a shit
How can we improve humanity? - by genetic engineering and bionics
What is the best advice or philosophy for living? - live and let live

What is religion? - an organized superstition
Why are there multiple religions? - some people believe in other kind of crap than others
Should religions be challenged? - sure
Is skepticism a good thing? - always
Why do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged? - because they fear that we are right
Which religion is right? - none
Can all religions be correct? - Nope
What does fear have to do with belief? - to frighten young children and uneducated people?
Do we have a need to believe in something? - no
What is spirituality? - a buzz-word, probably invented by a religious marketing-droid

Can religion and science coexist? - not really
What’s the difference between religion and science? - religion is BS
Can a religion change with society? - yes
Was man created or did he evolve? - evolve

Is there a God? - no
What is the definition of God? - no-one agrees on that one.
What gives you certainty in your belief? - not applicable
How do you deal with doubt? - not applicable
Who created God? - mommy and daddy God?
Is God male or female? - last time I heard that it was a kind of force-field hoovering somewhere around in hyperspace
What does God need from us? - nothing
Who is/are the Messiah(s)? - Steve Jobs
Who is the Devil? - anyone who apposes ;)
Which truth is right? - the truth

Is the holy-book(s) literally true? - no
What is the origin of the holy book(s)? - various places on Earth
How do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.? - I don't
Can we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest? - that is why we have so many sects

What is morality? - something that helps up to get around in social groups
Is there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures? - no, each culture has its own morals
Where does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from? - Evolution and upbringing
Is altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity? - sure

What is sin? - invented nonsense to make people feel guilty about themselves
What is the punishment for sin? - stoning
Is thought the same as deed? - no, if that would have been the case then all people will have to spend their lifetimes in jail
Does God want to test us? Why? - Silly question to someone who doesn't believe that God exists

Should a person have sex before marriage? - sure
Is masturbation a sin? - no, it is a necessity
What determines sexual orientation? - genes
Why is God interested in our sexual behavior? - he, she or it isn't
Should women be treated differently than men? - yes, in certain aspects; no in others

Do we have free will? - to a certain extend
Is everything predetermined? - no
What entity predetermines fate or destiny?- money and health

Why is there suffering?  - there are many reasons, religion is one of them
What is best path to happiness? - I also vote for endorphins
Does God intercede in human tragedies? - are you serious?

Does prayer work? - no
If so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters? - either he doesn't give a shit or he doesn't exists
If not, why pray? - I don't
Does meditation work? - probably, I never tried it though
How does meditation work? - don't know

What is a soul? - someone who loves soul music?
Do animals have souls? - don't know
Does a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body? - that is BS
If a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up? - question fail
What purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it? - Huh??

Is there an Afterlife? - no
Where is it, where do we go after death? under ground or in the fire
Why do we need an afterlife? - we don't

When does life begin? - when the sperm enters the egg
When should abortion be allowed? - you mean under which conditions or a time frame?
Is it ever appropriate to kill another person? - yes

What are supernatural beliefs? - beliefs in something that can't be proven
Are there extraterrestrials? - yes
Who are they? - Alf, E.T., Mork from Ork, etc.
Do psychics work, and if you are religious, are they allowed? - No, it doesn't work
Where do the voices in our heads come from? - from your brain

Will there be a doomsday? - if the religious fruitcakes have their go then yes
What is the greatest danger facing man’s existence? - religion
How do we stop conflict? - by killing everyone who doesn't agree with us
Should different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife?  - they are great for the tourism industry
Should political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy? - NO WAY

Why do we exist?
- Coz of coitus.
What is the best thing about existing?
- sex. food. video games
What is our purpose?
- nada. Oh, to diss religion
Is the world a better place for having had humans in it?
- Nono, I made it better  :D
Which truth is right?
- mine

Is the holy-book(s) literally true?
- they're true nonsense
What is the origin of the holy book(s)?
- wood pulp + writings of a nut
How do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.?
- Don't.
Can we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest?
- err... you mean making cults/sects?

What is morality?
- sort of a social contract. You stab me, I don't stab you.
Is there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures?
- Nope
Where does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from?
- reason.
Is altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity?
- definitely possible.

What is sin?
- ask a theist.
What is the punishment for sin?
- a mid summer holiday while clad in full artic gear.
Is thought the same as deed?
- huh? no.
Does God want to test us? Why?
- not applicable. ok... because he's bored.

Should a person have sex before marriage?
- why not?
Is masturbation a sin?
- no
What determines sexual orientation?
- genetics
Why is God interested in our sexual behavior?
- he doesn't exist , darn it. But if he does, so that he gets to see straight pornography.
Should women be treated differently than men?
Yes in some aspects, no in others, but same level of respect.

Do we have free will?
- yeah... until someone goes alpha on you. Shit happens.  
Is everything predetermined?
- no
What entity predetermines fate or destiny?
- no such thing

Why is there suffering?
- because not everything goes our way.
What is best path to happiness?
- endorphins.
Does God intercede in human tragedies?
- what? stupid question.

Does prayer work?
- no.
If so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters?
- he was bored.
If not, why pray?
- don't.
Does meditation work?
- sorta.
How does meditation work?
- letting yourself just relax, like a reboot button when your head is all stressed up.

What is a soul?
- no such thing
Do animals have souls?
- no
Does a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body?
- *pffft*
If a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up?
- oink oink?
What purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it?
- meow

Is there an Afterlife?
- no
Where is it, where do we go after death?
- the barbecue pit.
Why do we need an afterlife?
- for a barbecue party.

When does life begin?
- after mum and dad had rattled the sack, sperm meets egg.
When should abortion be allowed?
- when the couple/mother is unable to care for the child, rape, when the pregnancy endangers the life of the mother.
Is it ever appropriate to kill another person?
- yeah.

What are supernatural beliefs?
- more bs
Are there extraterrestrials?
- don't know, but I'm vouching for yes.
Who are they?
- no idea.
Do psychics work, and if you are religious, are they allowed?
- Only to steal your money.
Where do the voices in our heads come from?
- its called HALLUCINATIONS.

Will there be a doomsday?
- when the Sun becomes a red giant, I guess. Or, when the religious starts another crusade.
What is the greatest danger facing man’s existence?
- religion
How do we stop conflict?
- everyone obey MY commands!! Or die.
Should different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife?
- not decided yet.
Should political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy?
- NO NO NO NO NO

I'll try and answer some of the questions.

The best philosophy for living is to go on your own journey, be yourself, and see meaning in everything. Everyone has a need to believe in something, whatever that something may be. Everything, including man, is a creation, and man evolves both physically and spiritually. There's a god, and what gives me certainty in that is my knowing. Women and men are different and so often it's appropriate to be treated differently. There's suffering because suffering, like anything else, is part of experiencing and learning. The soul is our true self, our true identity, and the brain is our interface with the physical world and our physical bodies. There's an afterlife. Sometimes it's "ok" to kill someone, depending on the circumstances. There are extraterrestrials, some have been on earth for thousands of years. Different cultures should be preserved.

Quote from: "pilchardo"I'll try and answer some of the questions.

The best philosophy for living is to go on your own journey, be yourself, and see meaning in everything.

I agree with everything here but the last.

Quote from: "pilchardo"Everyone has a need to believe in something, whatever that something may be.

I see no reason to believe in anything, let alone needing to believe in something.

Quote from: "pilchardo"Everything, including man, is a creation, and man evolves both physically and spiritually.

When you say something like this to people who you normally converse with, I'm sure there is no contention as they are likely to already accept certain things that you do as well, however you'll find that when you're talking a larger amount of people that you need to back up statements of this kind.

Quote from: "pilchardo"There's a god, and what gives me certainty in that is my knowing.

Again as before, statements like this are not to just be accepted as you have boldly stated.

Quote from: "pilchardo"Women and men are different and so often it's appropriate to be treated differently. There's suffering because suffering, like anything else, is part of experiencing and learning. The soul is our true self, our true identity, and the brain is our interface with the physical world and our physical bodies. There's an afterlife. Sometimes it's "ok" to kill someone, depending on the circumstances. There are extraterrestrials, some have been on earth for thousands of years. Different cultures should be preserved.

Ok... stop preaching please.

Quote from: "Davin"When you say something like this to people who you normally converse with, I'm sure there is no contention as they are likely to already accept certain things that you do as well, however you'll find that when you're talking a larger amount of people that you need to back up statements of this kind.

Not if I'm merely giving my point of view, which is what the OP is asking.

Quote from: "Davin"Again as before, statements like this are not to just be accepted as you have boldly stated.

Again, just giving my answers to some of the OP's questions.

Quote from: "Davin"Ok... stop preaching please.

Again, just giving my answers to some of the OP's questions. I'm sorry if you consider that preaching, but preaching is something different.

Quote from: "pilchardo"Again, just giving my answers to some of the OP's questions.

The purpose of the OP was to develop thoughtful answers to those questions...not just to blurt out what you believe.  And, IMO, many of your stated beliefs couldn't possibly be based on rationally evaluating said beliefs.

QuoteI'm sorry if you consider that preaching, but preaching is something different.

preaching is stating beliefs without evidence.  I'm going to go add that definition to the rules for clarity since I'm tired of having to tell people.

The dictionary that I looked at doesn't say anything about preaching being what you say it is. I don't want to be seen as preaching and I'm sorry if you thought I was, so could you tell me which dictionary definition you're using?

Quote from: "pilchardo"The dictionary that I looked at doesn't say anything about preaching being what you say it is. I don't want to be seen as preaching and I'm sorry if you thought I was, so could you tell me which dictionary definition you're using?

we are using the definition now in the rules...I don't think there is a single word for "don't make statements without backing them up" so we adopted 'preaching' as a short way to define the unwanted action.  And how it is being used here appropriately fits into some ways the word preach is defined: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/preach (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/preach)  If you can think of another single word we should be using by all means suggest it but we aren't going to change the spirit of the rules.

Quote from: "Whitney"

Quote from: "pilchardo"The dictionary that I looked at doesn't say anything about preaching being what you say it is. I don't want to be seen as preaching and I'm sorry if you thought I was, so could you tell me which dictionary definition you're using?

we are using the definition now in the rules...I don't think there is a single word for "don't make statements without backing them up" so we adopted 'preaching' as a short way to define the unwanted action.  And how it is being used here appropriately fits into some ways the word preach is defined: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/preach (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/preach)  If you can think of another single word we should be using by all means suggest it but we aren't going to change the spirit of the rules.

According to the OP, the purpose is to "answer these questions for yourselves" and "just have fun with the philosophical questions of life". It's not easy to respond to the OP in the spirit in which it is intended without risking being seen as what you call "preaching".

Quote from: "pilchardo"According to the OP, the purpose is to "answer these questions for yourselves" and "just have fun with the philosophical questions of life". It's not easy to respond to the OP in the spirit in which it is intended without risking being seen as what you call "preaching".

Not sure if you read the revised rules but I worded it so that you could answer with your view but then would need to defend why you have such a view if challenged.

If you can't do that then, well, don't respond.

Quote from: "Whitney"

Quote from: "pilchardo"According to the OP, the purpose is to "answer these questions for yourselves" and "just have fun with the philosophical questions of life". It's not easy to respond to the OP in the spirit in which it is intended without risking being seen as what you call "preaching".

Not sure if you read the revised rules but I worded it so that you could answer with your view but then would need to defend why you have such a view if challenged.

If you can't do that then, well, don't respond.

There's clearly a conflict between your rules and the stated intention of the OP.

Quote from: "pilchardo"

Quote from: "Whitney"

Quote from: "pilchardo"According to the OP, the purpose is to "answer these questions for yourselves" and "just have fun with the philosophical questions of life". It's not easy to respond to the OP in the spirit in which it is intended without risking being seen as what you call "preaching".

Not sure if you read the revised rules but I worded it so that you could answer with your view but then would need to defend why you have such a view if challenged.

If you can't do that then, well, don't respond.

There's clearly a conflict between your rules and the stated intention of the OP.

1) no there isn't, you can respond to the OP but if someone asks you to defend a claim you would then be expected to back it up...if you have a reasoned view to begin with there shouldn't be any reason to complain about such a requirement.
2) rules override anything stated by a non-mod

I didn't make any claims, I just said what I believe, which is different, and no one asked me to defend what I said, which wouldn't matter anyway as I made no claim.

Quote from: "pilchardo"

Quote from: "Whitney"

Quote from: "pilchardo"According to the OP, the purpose is to "answer these questions for yourselves" and "just have fun with the philosophical questions of life". It's not easy to respond to the OP in the spirit in which it is intended without risking being seen as what you call "preaching".

Not sure if you read the revised rules but I worded it so that you could answer with your view but then would need to defend why you have such a view if challenged.

If you can't do that then, well, don't respond.

There's clearly a conflict between your rules and the stated intention of the OP.

The only definition that you need to understand and work by is Whitney's. If you start to argue you will be banned. If you don't appreciate what you have just been told and continue to behave as you are you will be banned. I've have seen this happen on a number of occasions.

Quote from: "pilchardo"I didn't make any claims, I just said what I believe, which is different, and no one asked me to defend what I said, which wouldn't matter anyway as I made no claim.

The reason this forum still exists and is as good as it is, is because Whitney has an excellent bullshit and troll detection capability. Do not for one nanosecond consider you are in a democracy here, it's a benevolent dictatorship and if you can't get your head around that then your time here is running out, fast.

Quote from: "pilchardo"I didn't make any claims, I just said what I believe, which is different, and no one asked me to defend what I said, which wouldn't matter anyway as I made no claim.

Quote from: "pilchardo"The best philosophy for living is to go on your own journey, be yourself, and see meaning in everything. Everyone has a need to believe in something, whatever that something may be. Everything, including man, is a creation, and man evolves both physically and spiritually. There's a god, and what gives me certainty in that is my knowing. Women and men are different and so often it's appropriate to be treated differently. There's suffering because suffering, like anything else, is part of experiencing and learning. The soul is our true self, our true identity, and the brain is our interface with the physical world and our physical bodies. There's an afterlife. Sometimes it's "ok" to kill someone, depending on the circumstances. There are extraterrestrials, some have been on earth for thousands of years. Different cultures should be preserved.

so since you made no claims...does that mean you don't state your above beliefs to be true?  And if so, why did you bother posting?

3.  To state to be true, especially when open to question; assert or maintain: claimed he had won the race; a candidate claiming many supporters. http://www.thefreedictionary.com/claim (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/claim)

I haven't asked you directly to defend what you said because I frankly don't expect a good answer and have better things to do...of course I also have better things to do than argue over someone who doesn't like a rule that requires they back up their beliefs.  This is the end of the discussion unless you have anything constructive to add, no one is making you stay around if you don't like the rules.

Quote from: "Pilchardo"Women and men are different and so often it's appropriate to be treated differently.

Black people and white people are different too, so I could just as easily make the claim that it's often appropriate for blacks to be treated differently than whites.

QuoteWhy do we exist?

Because we gradually evolved from other life forms into the beings we are today.

QuoteWhat is the best thing about existing?

Not sure. Probably just having fun and enjoying life.

QuoteWhat is our purpose?

Whatever you want it to be.

QuoteIs the world a better place for having had humans in it?

Most likely, no.

QuoteHow can we improve humanity?

By trying our best to reduce irrational thinking, for starters.

QuoteWhat is the best advice or philosophy for living?

Live life; have fun.

QuoteWhat is religion?

An ideology invoking the supernatural.

QuoteWhy are there multiple religions?

Because there are multiple people.

QuoteShould religions be challenged?

Like everything else, yes.

QuoteIs skepticism a good thing?

Undoubtedly.

QuoteWhy do people get angry when their beliefs are challenged?

Because of how ideologies and memes work.

QuoteWhich religion is right?

None, most likely.

QuoteCan all religions be correct?

I don't see how, as many contradict each other.

QuoteWhat does fear have to do with belief?

Fear of the unknown, death (the biggest unknown), and places like Hell are a very large part of why we have religion, and so much of it, today. Fear is a natural part of many beliefs.

QuoteDo we have a need to believe in something?

I don't know if we have a need to, but I definitely think that we as humans have a tendency to.

QuoteWhat is spirituality?

Imaginary.

QuoteCan religion and science coexist?

Yes, but they shouldn't.

QuoteWhat’s the difference between religion and science?

Religions are primitive ideologies, made when we didn't understand how the world works; they resist change, and keep believers believing in them for unintellectual reasons. Science is our best tool for finding out how the world works; change is a fundamental part of it, and it encourages people to stop believing in a theory is there's a better alternative.

QuoteCan a religion change with society?

Obviously, yes.

QuoteWas man created or did he evolve?

Evolved.

QuoteIs there a God?

Most likely, no.

QuoteWhat is the definition of God?

That which is worshiped as a god.

QuoteWhat gives you certainty in your belief?

I'm not certain.

QuoteHow do you deal with doubt?

I try my best to embrace it.

QuoteWho created God?

The minds of men.

QuoteIs God male or female?

Irrelevant.

QuoteWhat does God need from us?

Our continued belief, or else he would cease to exist.

QuoteWho is/are the Messiah(s)?

No one, most likely.

QuoteWho is the Devil?

There is none, most likely.

QuoteWhat is faith?

A blind and irrational belief in that which there is no evidence.

QuoteWhat is a fact?

An objective truth about our universe.

QuoteHow can we tell which is which?

By looking at the evidence.

QuoteWhat is truth?

That which conforms to reality.

QuoteHow do we determine truth?

With science. Science can never be 100% accurate, but it gives us the most accurate picture of our world.
Which truth is right?

QuoteIs the holy-book(s) literally true?

Probably not (if we're talking about the Torah/Bible/Qur'an, then definitely not).

QuoteWhat is the origin of the holy book(s)?

Primitive men.

QuoteHow do we accept a holy book that positively portrays unacceptable behaviors like slavery, incest, murder, etc.?

We don't.

QuoteCan we take what we like about a religion/belief system and make our own version and throw out the rest?

YES. That is the best thing you can do in regards to an ideology.

QuoteWhat is morality?

Opinions about what is right and what is wrong.

QuoteIs there a moral yardstick that applies to all cultures?

If by "yardstick", you mean "moral standard", then no.

QuoteWhere does morality, or our “conscience,” comes from?

Society, and evolution.

QuoteIs altruism or morality possible without belief in a deity?

Yes, obviously.

QuoteWhat is sin?

I view it as a synonym for evil.

QuoteWhat is the punishment for sin?

Whatever your consequences are for doing the action.

QuoteIs thought the same as deed?

Unless your thoughts have the same consequences as a deed, then no.

QuoteDoes God want to test us? Why?

I don't even think he exists, so no.

QuoteShould a person have sex before marriage?

If they want, sure.

QuoteIs masturbation a sin?

Not to me.

QuoteWhat determines sexual orientation?

Most likely a mixture of genetics and environment.

QuoteWhy is God interested in our sexual behavior?

He isn't.

QuoteShould women be treated differently than men?

No.

QuoteDo we have free will?

Most likely, no.

QuoteIs everything predetermined?

More or less, probably.

QuoteWhat entity predetermines fate or destiny?

None, most likely.

QuoteWhy is there suffering?

Because we've evolved to feel pain when there's a danger to our well-being.

QuoteWhat is best path to happiness?

Doing that which makes you happy.

QuoteDoes God intercede in human tragedies?

Most likely, no.

QuoteDoes prayer work?

No.

QuoteIf so, why does God allow holocausts, and disasters?

He doesn't.

QuoteIf not, why pray?

I think praying can be useful for secular reasons, but they're are probably better alternatives (such as meditation).

QuoteDoes meditation work?

Yes.

QuoteHow does meditation work?

It calms the mind.

QuoteWhat is a soul?

An imaginary thing, most likely.

QuoteDo animals have souls?

Probably not.

QuoteDoes a soul have the same thoughts and feelings when outside the body?

They probably don't exist, so no.

QuoteIf a soul does not carry our memories, then what is a soul since it is our memories that make us up?

Like I said, something imaginary.

QuoteWhat purpose does a brain serve if a soul can exist and feel without it?

None.

QuoteIs there an Afterlife?

Probably not.

QuoteWhere is it, where do we go after death?

In the ground, most likely.

QuoteWhy do we need an afterlife?

We don't.

QuoteWhen does life begin?

When it begins. This is a pretty meaningless question -- I think what the author really meant was "when does a pre-born baby become a person?"

QuoteWhen should abortion be allowed?

Whenever a woman wants to have one.

QuoteIs it ever appropriate to kill another person?

Yes, although I'd dispute that pre-born babies are people (at least up until a certain point).

QuoteWhat are supernatural beliefs?

Beliefs in something above nature.

QuoteAre there extraterrestrials?

Probably, although we don't know.

QuoteWho are they?

Hell if I know.

QuoteDo psychics work, and if you are religious, are they allowed?

I'm pretty certain they don't work.

QuoteWhere do the voices in our heads come from?

Our heads.

QuoteWill there be a doomsday?

Probably, but it will because we have doomed ourselves.

QuoteWhat is the greatest danger facing man’s existence?

Ourselves.

QuoteHow do we stop conflict?

By promoting peace, tolerance, and rational thinking.

QuoteShould different cultures be preserved, or are our cultural differences the source of strife?

I would take it on a case-by-case basis.

QuoteShould political leaders invoke a deity in decisions or policy?

No, I don't think they should.

By the way, the original poster got these questions from here (http://thenatureofexistence.com/about/the-questions/), if that hasn't been found out already.

EDIT: Never mind, it was found out in the second post

Quote from: "Whitney"

Quote from: "pilchardo"I didn't make any claims, I just said what I believe, which is different, and no one asked me to defend what I said, which wouldn't matter anyway as I made no claim.

Quote from: "pilchardo"The best philosophy for living is to go on your own journey, be yourself, and see meaning in everything. Everyone has a need to believe in something, whatever that something may be. Everything, including man, is a creation, and man evolves both physically and spiritually. There's a god, and what gives me certainty in that is my knowing. Women and men are different and so often it's appropriate to be treated differently. There's suffering because suffering, like anything else, is part of experiencing and learning. The soul is our true self, our true identity, and the brain is our interface with the physical world and our physical bodies. There's an afterlife. Sometimes it's "ok" to kill someone, depending on the circumstances. There are extraterrestrials, some have been on earth for thousands of years. Different cultures should be preserved.

so since you made no claims...does that mean you don't state your above beliefs to be true?  And if so, why did you bother posting?

3.  To state to be true, especially when open to question; assert or maintain: claimed he had won the race; a candidate claiming many supporters. http://www.thefreedictionary.com/claim (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/claim)

I haven't asked you directly to defend what you said because I frankly don't expect a good answer and have better things to do...of course I also have better things to do than argue over someone who doesn't like a rule that requires they back up their beliefs.  This is the end of the discussion unless you have anything constructive to add, no one is making you stay around if you don't like the rules.

No I don't state them to be true. I state them to be my beliefs. That's the difference, and that's what I meant when I said I make no claim. So in the spirit of the OP's stated intention, is it ok with you if I respond by stating my beliefs? And if not, would it be ok if I stated my beliefs on a thread in the Laid back lounge, or does your rule, the one that you rephrased, also apply there?

I have to side with Pilchardo here, Whitney. He was answering a couple of questions that the original post asked him to answer; I don't think he should be required to back up his beliefs with evidence when he's just doing this.

EDIT: Never mind -- if someone asks him to back up a claim, then he should be able to.

Quote from: "LegendarySandwich"I have to side with Pilchardo here, Whitney. He was answering a couple of questions that the original post asked him to answer; I don't think he should be required to back up his beliefs with evidence when he's just doing this.

EDIT: Never mind -- if someone asks him to back up a claim, then he should be able to.

I'm not a gnostic theist, and I also make no claims, except to have certain beliefs. Whitney probably assumed that I was making some sort of claim but clearly I was merely responding to the OP's invitation to answer some questions in a lighthearted spirit and the OP's thread makes it clear that it's just a bit of fun.

Quote from: "pilchardo"No I don't state them to be true. I state them to be my beliefs.

I'm glad we have established that you have beliefs which don't consider true  

QuoteThat's the difference, and that's what I meant when I said I make no claim. So in the spirit of the OP's stated intention, is it ok with you if I respond by stating my beliefs?

I already said you could as long as if someone asked you about them that you'd back up your position...why is that too much to ask?  If you can't even explain why you hold something as a belief you shouldn't claim it as a belief.

QuoteAnd if not, would it be ok if I stated my beliefs on a thread in the Laid back lounge, or does your rule, the one that you rephrased, also apply there?

I think the rules pretty clearly state that would be not ok because someone didn't ask you about your beliefs.  You can only just state your beliefs out of the blue if they are accompanied by supporting evidence and/or reason.

So if someone comes along and asks me to back up a belief that I might have mentioned, can I just say that I'm not in a position to be able to do so?

Quote from: "pilchardo"So if someone comes along and asks me to back up a belief that I might have mentioned, can I just say that I'm not in a position to be able to do so?

moderators let stuff like that slide when it is honest but continually stating your beliefs and are unable to support any of them without even the slightest bit of reason that's going to fall back under preaching.

We have this rule to promote discussion.

Quote from: "Whitney"

Quote from: "pilchardo"So if someone comes along and asks me to back up a belief that I might have mentioned, can I just say that I'm not in a position to be able to do so?

moderators let stuff like that slide when it is honest but continually stating your beliefs and are unable to support any of them without even the slightest bit of reason that's going to fall back under preaching.

We have this rule to promote discussion.

If I'm asked to state and / or talk about my beliefs, and I do, and then if they ask me to back them up, and I say that I'm not in a position to be able to do so, and if that happens continually, does it count as preaching?

Quote from: "pilchardo"

Quote from: "Whitney"

Quote from: "pilchardo"So if someone comes along and asks me to back up a belief that I might have mentioned, can I just say that I'm not in a position to be able to do so?

moderators let stuff like that slide when it is honest but continually stating your beliefs and are unable to support any of them without even the slightest bit of reason that's going to fall back under preaching.

We have this rule to promote discussion.

If I'm asked to state and / or talk about my beliefs, and I do, and then if they ask me to back them up, and I say that I'm not in a position to be able to do so, and if that happens continually, does it count as preaching?

if you start out your beliefs with something like "I have no clue why I hold this belief but..." then you would be okay on the preaching rule but I might start thinking you are just here to annoy people (aka troll).

I'll bear that in mind, ie I'll try not to go on about my beliefs out of the blue. But if anyone asks me about them or starts a thread where it's clear that they're inviting people to talk about their philosophical position or their beliefs, I guess it's ok to mention them. I'll just be sure to make it clear again that they're beliefs, not claims.

Quote from: "pilchardo"I'll bear that in mind, ie I'll try not to go on about my beliefs out of the blue. But if anyone asks me about them or starts a thread where it's clear that they're inviting people to talk about their philosophical position or their beliefs, I guess it's ok to mention them. I'll just be sure to make it clear again that they're beliefs, not claims.

You should also take heed that beliefs are not exempt from scrutiny.

Quote from: "Ultima22689"

Quote from: "pilchardo"I'll bear that in mind, ie I'll try not to go on about my beliefs out of the blue. But if anyone asks me about them or starts a thread where it's clear that they're inviting people to talk about their philosophical position or their beliefs, I guess it's ok to mention them. I'll just be sure to make it clear again that they're beliefs, not claims.

You should also take heed that beliefs are not exempt from scrutiny.

Yes I understand that. I just wanted to be clear on the "rules" about talking about beliefs. If I want to talk about my beliefs I'll be sure to clarify, that way there won't be any more confusion. If you wish to scrutinise my beliefs you can of course do that, for yourself. However the last thing I'd want is for anybody to try and preach at or convert anybody else.

Quote from: "pilchardo"Yes I understand that. I just wanted to be clear on the "rules" about talking about beliefs. If I want to talk about my beliefs I'll be sure to clarify, that way there won't be any more confusion. If you wish to scrutinise my beliefs you can of course do that, for yourself. However the last thing I'd want is for anybody to try and preach at or convert anybody else.

What you are not understanding is that HAF has the no preaching rule to encourage discussion/debate...it would be okay from time to time to just mention your beliefs then admit that you can't possibly have a reason for having such beliefs (why in the world you'd want to claim a belief you can't explain is beyond me).

If you just want a place where you can comment then not expect to have to ever explain your views, this isn't it.

Quote from: "Whitney"

Quote from: "pilchardo"Yes I understand that. I just wanted to be clear on the "rules" about talking about beliefs. If I want to talk about my beliefs I'll be sure to clarify, that way there won't be any more confusion. If you wish to scrutinise my beliefs you can of course do that, for yourself. However the last thing I'd want is for anybody to try and preach at or convert anybody else.

What you are not understanding is that HAF has the no preaching rule to encourage discussion/debate...it would be okay from time to time to just mention your beliefs then admit that you can't possibly have a reason for having such beliefs (why in the world you'd want to claim a belief you can't explain is beyond me).

If you just want a place where you can comment then not expect to have to ever explain your views, this isn't it.

I never said I did.

Quote from: "LegendarySandwich"

Quote from: "Pilchardo"Women and men are different and so often it's appropriate to be treated differently.

Black people and white people are different too, so I could just as easily make the claim that it's often appropriate for blacks to be treated differently than whites.

That's your prerogative.

Quote from: "pilchardo"

Quote from: "LegendarySandwich"

Quote from: "Pilchardo"Women and men are different and so often it's appropriate to be treated differently.

Black people and white people are different too, so I could just as easily make the claim that it's often appropriate for blacks to be treated differently than whites.

That's your prerogative.

I think your irony detector has malfunctioned. LS is illustrating that it is as inappropriate to be sexist as it is to be racist.

The irony being that I was being neither.

Quote from: "pilchardo"The irony being that I was being neither.

Why, exactly, is it okay to treat women and men differently but not whites and blacks differently? Care to explain?

Quote from: "pilchardo"The irony being that I was being neither.

 I was not saying you were. I was just pointing out that LS wasn't either.

Quote from: "LegendarySandwich"

Quote from: "pilchardo"The irony being that I was being neither.

Why, exactly, is it okay to treat women and men differently but not whites and blacks differently? Care to explain?

Start a thread about that and I'll answer your question there. Unless you want to derail this thread too.

Sexism: Is It Acceptable? (http://happyatheistforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=6738)