Moral puzzle

[billy rubin]

please forgive me reviving this, but its super interesting.

if theres a missing puzzle piece out of the box, the nature of the completed puzzle has changed. if the piece is unrecoverable, the puzzle is now complete, but with a hole in it.

conjecturing a theoretically different task--a puzzle with no holez-- means altering the nature of the puzzle from that which exists in the real world to a theoretical ideal form that it imitates but which does not actually exist.

which is the real puzzle? the one with or the one without the missing piece?

[No one]

Only if she gives me $1,000,000,000 each time she makes this claim.