Happy Atheist Forum

Community => Social Issues and Causes => Topic started by: philosoraptor on August 10, 2010, 12:14:27 AM

Title: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: philosoraptor on August 10, 2010, 12:14:27 AM
I apologize if this is a dupe topic-I looked, but didn't see anything else that really fit.

So here's my dilemma.  I already wrote about my Christian coworker going apeshit over Andrea Yates (http://www.happyatheistforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=724&start=2040#p75336).  Of course, that was only one incident that occurred at my job.

Back when I first started, my manager told me upfront they curse a lot in my department, which didn't really bother me.  My coworkers dropped f-bombs and Jesus Christs and shit and bitch like it was nothing.  One day, after hanging up with a particularly difficult customer, I said god damnit.  My one coworker teased me and said not to take the Lord's name in vain.  I told him I was an atheist, so it didn't really matter to me.  He immediately started grilling me about why I was atheist.  I told him I didn't really think it was a good topic to discuss at work, but he pressed me and I gave him the simplified answer that I thought the world had to much evil in it for a loving God to exist.  He gave me a hard time about my answer until I told I really didn't want to discuss it.  About here is the point where it came out that all of my coworkers are Catholic and attend church together.

A few days ago, my one coworker says she finally got her daughter on the wait list to be baptised, but that she had to make a $150 donation fist.  I was incredulous.  I asked how was it that they could charge a fee for something they believe is required to get into heaven.  I was told this was not appropriate, but apparently, it was fine back when my coworker grilled me about my beliefs.  Go figure.  Additionally, my coworkers would talk about church all the time in front of me, which made me feel like an outcast.  One day, the coworker who went off on the Andrea Yates thing made a snide remark about my lack of beliefs (well what do you do on Sundays, since you don't go to church?), but I let it slide in the interest of trying to maintain workplace harmony.  Oy.

Fast forward to today.  They terminated me.  My boss told me I was a nice person, and a very hard and dependable worker, but that I wasn't cut out for the job.  WTF?  I was a model employee, but not cut out for the job?  That doesn't even make sense. I feel like this was really code for I didn't fit in, because I wasn't Catholic or a raging bigot like my coworkers (the blatant racism and discrimination against customers is a juicy story all on its own).

So...here's my question.  I've already spoken with their outside HR rep about this, and am in the process of filing a complaint with the EEOC, but are there any atheist or secular organizations I might talk to regarding the religious discrimination?  I want to do every thing I can, because the way this went down is really ridiculous.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: pinkocommie on August 10, 2010, 12:35:14 AM
Doooooood that sucks.  I would email the FFRF and ACLU and see what they say.  If they can't help you, they might at least be able to point you in the right direction.  I'm sorry you have to go back to looking for work, but that place sounded shitty enough that you will probably be better off in the long run not working there.  Sorry man!  :(
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Thumpalumpacus on August 10, 2010, 01:25:08 AM
Sorry to hear about this.  Pinko's advice is sound.

Also, when you file for unemployment benefits, ask your case-worker about the issue.  Lay it out just as you have here.  Make sure that you mention this to your case-worker.  If your company decides to argue against your claim, it may be vital that this info is documented ASAP.

Out of curiousity, did you mention this issue to HR before you were termed?  If so, demand a copy of that report.  In most states, you have a right to examine and make copies of your employee records; and such a report would be decisive in settling your claim in your favor.

Good luck on, ahem, nailing them to the cross.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: philosoraptor on August 10, 2010, 02:07:00 AM
I didn't even get a chance to talk to HR until today-she's located out of our office, and my hours were as such that by the time I was done working, she was no longer in her office.  I did incidentally contact the FFRF and AAI, so we'll see if that goes anywhere.  I'll have to look into unemployment-I may not have worked there long enough to qualify.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: humblesmurph on August 10, 2010, 03:50:56 AM
Wow, that is awful.  Did you confront the asshole who fired you about the obvious discrimination?  What did (s)he say?
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: philosoraptor on August 10, 2010, 03:57:27 AM
I didn't confront anyone-there were more than a few times when my coworkers said offensive things that I called them out and told them I found it offensive.  They obviously know where I stand on it, which I suspect is why I was let go.  I figured, rather than start a scene, it was better to exit gracefully and file the appropriate paper work.  I'll let the EEOC do the dirty work.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Whitney on August 10, 2010, 05:01:38 AM
If you don't mind potentially being interviewed for the tv or paper; issue a press release and personally contact your local news outlets....I don't know about where you live but around here anything atheist related has a good chance of making the news.   Figuring out how to pitch it as a story worth telling above and beyond being a basic discrimination case will increase the chances of it making it on the news.

It may not do anything to fix what has already been done but might make them think twice about doing it to someone else.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: philosoraptor on August 10, 2010, 05:12:14 AM
I actually thought about doing that, Whitney.  No harm in drafting a story and seeing if any of the local news outlets take a nibble.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: NothingSacred on August 10, 2010, 05:24:14 AM
Id say fight it out not just because of the fact that you have the freedom to believe or disbelieve as you wish but because companies think they can dismiss and dispose of hardworking emplyees as they wish. I was fired from my previous job because I had akidney infection and they had a rule that you couldn't miss more than 2 days a year. It was a HOSPITAL and it was UNION ..these sorts of things make my blood boil. People have bills to pay and families to feed.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Tank on August 10, 2010, 06:49:21 AM
Philo

Is religion the only issue or is it also that your intelligence makes your boss concerned about their own job? Are there other issues than the obvious one?
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Will on August 10, 2010, 07:40:04 AM
Quote from: "philosoraptor"About here is the point where it came out that all of my coworkers are Catholic and attend church together.
Oh crap.  :eek:
Quote from: "philosoraptor"Fast forward to today.  They terminated me.  My boss told me I was a nice person, and a very hard and dependable worker, but that I wasn't cut out for the job.  WTF?  I was a model employee, but not cut out for the job?  That doesn't even make sense. I feel like this was really code for I didn't fit in, because I wasn't Catholic or a raging bigot like my coworkers (the blatant racism and discrimination against customers is a juicy story all on its own).

So...here's my question.  I've already spoken with their outside HR rep about this, and am in the process of filing a complaint with the EEOC, but are there any atheist or secular organizations I might talk to regarding the religious discrimination?  I want to do every thing I can, because the way this went down is really ridiculous.
I'm not an attorney, so take this with a grain of salt, but many employers these days fire people for what in reality are entirely inappropriate reasons, but on paper they're fine. Though you may have been fired for being an atheist, I have to imagine that would be very, very difficult to prove in court. Contact the ACLU. Even though we're a bit swamped right now, I'm pretty sure they can give you a list of options, possibly including the names of local attorneys that specialize in cases like yours.

I'm sorry you've lost your job. I got fired once and it sucks. Still, keep your head up and move forward. Maybe your next job will feature coworkers that aren't raging lunatics.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: philosoraptor on August 10, 2010, 11:35:11 PM
Unfortunately, the religious issues are just the tip of the iceberg.  As I mentioned earlier, bigotry and racism ran rampant through my department.  I witnessed an exchange between my boss and my coworker where he basically told her not to do something for an Indian customer that he would've done if the person had been white.  Religious issues aside, someone needs to know about the racism and do something about it-it's not fair to the customers or the other people working there.  I was basically told that the way you treat a customer was dependent on their race or color.  Whenever my coworkers made racially inappropriate or bigoted comments, I objected to them.  I think the fact that I wasn't willing to discriminate was another contributing factor to what happened.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Thumpalumpacus on August 10, 2010, 11:36:38 PM
Quote from: "philosoraptor"Unfortunately, the religious issues are just the tip of the iceberg.  As I mentioned earlier, bigotry and racism ran rampant through my department.  I witnessed an exchange between my boss and my coworker where he basically told her not to do something for an Indian customer that he would've done if the person had been white.  Religious issues aside, someone needs to know about the racism and do something about it-it's not fair to the customers or the other people working there.  I was basically told that the way you treat a customer was dependent on their race or color.  Whenever my coworkers made racially inappropriate or bigoted comments, I objected to them.  I think the fact that I wasn't willing to discriminate was another contributing factor to what happened.

Oh lordy, and you didn't mention this to HR?
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: philosoraptor on August 11, 2010, 12:28:52 AM
Oh no, I mentioned it to HR.  I told her everything.  Someone at that office should be shitting bricks right about now.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Thumpalumpacus on August 11, 2010, 07:23:54 AM
Good!

The very fact that there's a record of an HR complaint from you gives you much stronger legs here.  Do keep us posted, and, again, best of luck.  Stick it to 'em.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Tank on August 11, 2010, 08:39:10 AM
Sounds like you inadvertently landed somewhere you really needed to be, to show up these peoples attitudes, God moves in mysterious ways  :blink:

On a more serious note. It's a real bugger that you ended up here because of the stress this could cause you. Stick to your guns on this, but not to the point where it is doing you harm with no end in sight. A good commander knows when to retreat as well as when to attack. Take care of yourself and keeps us posted.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: karadan on August 11, 2010, 09:03:04 AM
Quote from: "philosoraptor"Unfortunately, the religious issues are just the tip of the iceberg.  As I mentioned earlier, bigotry and racism ran rampant through my department.  I witnessed an exchange between my boss and my coworker where he basically told her not to do something for an Indian customer that he would've done if the person had been white.  Religious issues aside, someone needs to know about the racism and do something about it-it's not fair to the customers or the other people working there.  I was basically told that the way you treat a customer was dependent on their race or color.  Whenever my coworkers made racially inappropriate or bigoted comments, I objected to them.  I think the fact that I wasn't willing to discriminate was another contributing factor to what happened.


It beggars belief that your willingness to be an upstanding and moral person has actually worked against you in your job!! What a bunch of assholes they must be. As was said before, in the long term, it is probably for the best seeing as it can't have been particularly nice working there under such conditions. I've had to work in oppressive environments before and it is soul destroying. Still, it is such a nasty feeling to be sacked - whatever the circumstances.

I hope you find something else really soon. You definitely have the brain for it.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: philosoraptor on August 12, 2010, 01:09:22 AM
Everyone I know tells me I'm better off.  Which is probably true, it just sucks right now because my SO's income is not enough to pay all the bills we have.  I'm hoping I can qualify for unemployment if I don't find something else soon.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Thumpalumpacus on August 12, 2010, 02:21:17 AM
Quote from: "philosoraptor"Everyone I know tells me I'm better off.  Which is probably true, it just sucks right now because my SO's income is not enough to pay all the bills we have.  I'm hoping I can qualify for unemployment if I don't find something else soon.

I'm unsure of NJ requirements, but the norm is that you are eligible for unemployment benefits so long as you weren't fired for cause, which is defined as having violated either a) explicitly stated corporate policy or safe operating procedures or b) state or federal law.

You'll probably get it.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: KDbeads on August 12, 2010, 04:16:42 AM
But you normally have to be there a certain number of days before eligible.  I think it's 90 in most states.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Thumpalumpacus on August 12, 2010, 04:37:43 AM
True enough.  I was assuming she had been.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: KebertX on August 12, 2010, 05:49:33 AM
Fuck them. Who wants to work with bigots?
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: philosoraptor on August 12, 2010, 06:16:50 AM
Quote from: "KebertX"Fuck them. Who wants to work with bigots?

Other bigots?

Even if my EEOC complaint goes nowhere, I hope it will at least shake things up and make them reevaluate the way they do business.  It's wait and see at this point.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Tank on August 12, 2010, 09:22:01 AM
Quote from: "philosoraptor"
Quote from: "KebertX"Fuck them. Who wants to work with bigots?

Other bigots?

Even if my EEOC complaint goes nowhere, I hope it will at least shake things up and make them reevaluate the way they do business.  It's wait and see at this point.

Heart says yes, head says no  :sigh:
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: philosoraptor on October 22, 2010, 01:32:32 AM
BUMPing this thread for an update ot the situation.

I FINALLY received back paper work from the EEOC yesterday.  I have a case worker, and they sent me copies of charge forms to review and initial, so it looks as though this thing is finally proceeding, slowly but surely!

Even if nothing really comes of it, I'm still glad I took the steps to do this.  Hopefully it will at least make them reconsider their lack of diversity and intolerance towards those who are different (or at least I can wish, right?).
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Thumpalumpacus on October 22, 2010, 06:19:15 AM
Best of luck, ma'am.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: AnimatedDirt on October 22, 2010, 06:11:15 PM
Quote from: "philosoraptor"Oh no, I mentioned it to HR.  I told her everything.  Someone at that office should be shitting bricks right about now.
First of all, this is so wrong.  Second...$150.00 to get baptized?  :)
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Asmodean on October 22, 2010, 07:03:05 PM
In my country and profession, I have the privilege to tell whoever to shove that job up his bottom if fired for imapropriate reasons. Would take me a day to find a new gig, and I'd spend half of it chilling in some cafe...

And still I can't seem to find just the right job...

Looks like I should consider myself lucky and shut up...  :sigh:
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: DropLogic on October 22, 2010, 10:05:34 PM
I can't find my OP about this issue.

I started at my company as a contractor hired on to roll out some equipment to the field sales people.  They liked my work ethic, intelligence, and fresh look on things, so they hired me after only 5 weeks.  Fast forward 2 years.  I've been promoted three times, gotten a raise at each performance review, and things are looking great.  I propose to my now wife, and go to a department party a couple of weeks later where I am congratulated by my supervisor, his boss, and the head of development.  This is where my professional life at this company went to hell.
My bosses boss drops this bomb on me: "So are you excited to finally move in with your fiance?"
Taken aback for a moment I reply, "oh, well we've actually lived together for about 6 years now." You'd think I killed someone from the looks on their faces.
All three of them give each other shifty eye'd glances and my supervisor then asks, "so what church do you go to?"
I replied that I don't go to a church.  Sensing the tension, I went to buy the next round of drinks.

From that day forward my life at this company has been hell.  I have received mediocre performance reviews.  My ideas on how to help the company move forward through this tough economy have been completely ignored.  I have been written up twice for insubordination due to my "tone" in meetings.  Once all of this started happening I knew I had to tip-toe.  However, it doesn't seem to matter what I do here.  I was moved to another department that is entirely outside of my expertise 2 months ago.  That tells me that they can't fire me, so they'll tuck me away somewhere they don't have to acknowledge me or interact with me.  
I can't report this to anyone because they're all religious and don't think religious discrimination is real.  I went to a friend of mine in HR who I trust implicitly, and she told me that I would be fighting an impossible battle.
So for now, I'm looking for work elsewhere...but no one wants to pay me near what I'm already making...and my bills aren't getting any cheaper.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Tank on October 23, 2010, 09:46:35 AM
Quote from: "philosoraptor"BUMPing this thread for an update ot the situation.

I FINALLY received back paper work from the EEOC yesterday.  I have a case worker, and they sent me copies of charge forms to review and initial, so it looks as though this thing is finally proceeding, slowly but surely!

Even if nothing really comes of it, I'm still glad I took the steps to do this.  Hopefully it will at least make them reconsider their lack of diversity and intolerance towards those who are different (or at least I can wish, right?).
Good news.
Title: Re: Religious Discrimination in the Workplace
Post by: Thumpalumpacus on October 23, 2010, 04:47:44 PM
Quote from: "DropLogic"I can't find my OP about this issue.

I started at my company as a contractor hired on to roll out some equipment to the field sales people.  They liked my work ethic, intelligence, and fresh look on things, so they hired me after only 5 weeks.  Fast forward 2 years.  I've been promoted three times, gotten a raise at each performance review, and things are looking great.  I propose to my now wife, and go to a department party a couple of weeks later where I am congratulated by my supervisor, his boss, and the head of development.  This is where my professional life at this company went to hell.
My bosses boss drops this bomb on me: "So are you excited to finally move in with your fiance?"
Taken aback for a moment I reply, "oh, well we've actually lived together for about 6 years now." You'd think I killed someone from the looks on their faces.
All three of them give each other shifty eye'd glances and my supervisor then asks, "so what church do you go to?"
I replied that I don't go to a church.  Sensing the tension, I went to buy the next round of drinks.

From that day forward my life at this company has been hell.  I have received mediocre performance reviews.  My ideas on how to help the company move forward through this tough economy have been completely ignored.  I have been written up twice for insubordination due to my "tone" in meetings.  Once all of this started happening I knew I had to tip-toe.  However, it doesn't seem to matter what I do here.  I was moved to another department that is entirely outside of my expertise 2 months ago.  That tells me that they can't fire me, so they'll tuck me away somewhere they don't have to acknowledge me or interact with me.  
I can't report this to anyone because they're all religious and don't think religious discrimination is real.  I went to a friend of mine in HR who I trust implicitly, and she told me that I would be fighting an impossible battle.
So for now, I'm looking for work elsewhere...but no one wants to pay me near what I'm already making...and my bills aren't getting any cheaper.

You can go to your EEOC board.  Before you do, make sure you're documenting everything.

Keep your head up, and don't back down.